Sound Research WIKINDX

List Resources

Displaying 1 - 7  of 7
Parameters
Order by

Ascending
Descending
 
Display options Hint
Use all checked: 
Use all displayed: 
Use all in list: 
Becker, H. S. (2010). Writing for social scientists: How to start and finish your thesis, book, or article. ReadHowYouWant. com.    
Added by: alexb44   Last edited by: alexb44 29/10/2026, 03:11
read

"Gusfield (1981) on the rhetoric of social science"

 
nice q

"Writing an early rough draft, then, shows you all the earlier decisions that now shape what you can write. You can’t “use” Marx if Durkheim’s ideas shaped your thinking. You can’t write about what the data you gathered don’t tell you about, or your method of storing them doesn’t let you use them for. You see what you have and don’t have, what you have already done and already know, and what’s left to do. You see that the only job left—even though you have just begun to write—is to make it all clearer." Chapter 2: PERSONA AND AUTHORITY

 
overcome academic pose to overcome academic prose

"lack of ready intelligibility [in scholarly writing], I believe, usually has little or nothing to do with the complexity of the subject matter, and nothing at all with profundity of thought. It has to do almost entirely with certain confusions of the academic writer about his own status. . . . In large part sociological habits of style stem from the time when sociologists had little status even with other academic men. Desire for status is one reason why academic men slip so easily into unintelligibility. . . . To overcome the academic prose you have first to overcome the academic pose. (Mills 1959, 218–19, emphasis in the original.)"

 
im a will rogers

"Some writers—I favor this persona myself—take a Will Rogers line. We are just plain folks who emphasize our similarity to ordinary people, rather than the differences. We may know a few things others don’t, but it’s nothing special. “Shucks, you’d of thought the same as me if you’d just been there to see what I seen. It’s just that I had the time or took the trouble to be there, and you didn’t or couldn’t, but let me tell you about it.” Something like that. (In fact, this whole book is an extended example of that persona.)"

 
we show allegiance through our terms

"Most sociological theories rely, for instance, on the idea that people remake society continuously by doing, day in and day out, the things that reaffirm that that is the way things are done. You might say that people create society by acting as though it existed. You might say, if you were a Marxist theorist, that people reproduce social relations through daily practice. If you were a symbolic interactionist, or an adherent of Berger and Luckmann, you might speak of the social construction of reality."

 
we say who we are, rather than what we mean

"These are not just different words. They express different thoughts. Still, not that different. Code words don’t always contain a core of unique meaning, but we still use them rather than some other words that might lead people to think that we belong, or would like to belong, to some other school of thought. The allegiance-signaling purpose of stylistic devices is clearest when the author says things that conflict with the theory the language signals, when the desire to say “I am a functionalist” or “I am a Marxist” overcomes the desire to say what you mean."

 
bad pracgtices ring on... imagine now with LLMs

"Why do editors do that? Because nothing better is available. Because the number of journals has increased astronomically and the number of knowledgeable people available to do the required peer review is not large enough to handle the load which Andrew Abbott, for many years editor of the American Journal of Sociology, tells us leads to this work being done not by the knowledgeable senior scholar the term “peer review” implies but rather by graduate students who jump at the chance to do this grown-up job (Abbott 1999, 190–91). And so the journals provide the raw material for another generation to learn bad habits from." Chapter 3: ONE RIGHT WAY

 
freewriting

"Once you know that writing a sentence down won’t hurt you, know it because you have tried it, you can do what I usually ask people to try: write whatever comes into your head, as fast as you can, without reference to outlines, notes, data, books, or any other aids. The object is to find out what you would like to say, what all your earlier work on the topic or project has already led you to believe. This is the device known to teachers of composition as “freewriting,” which I first heard of in Elbow (1981, 13–19) and then found in a less academic form in Anne Lamott’s Bird by Bird (1994, 21–27), where it got the less academic name of “shitty first draft."

 
our thoughts on a certain matter form over time, not just when we write

"In short, by the time we come to write something, we have done a lot of thinking. We have an investment in everything we have already worked out that commits us to a point of view and a way of handling the problem. We probably couldn’t, even if we wanted to, handle the problem any differently from the way we will end up handling it. We are committed, not by the choice of a word, but by the analysis we have already done, by all our prior thinking and actions. That’s why it makes no difference how we begin. We chose our path and destination a long time ago."

 
obsidian ideas

"Using such a program, you begin the analysis by taking notes on what you’ve already written, putting each idea in an appropriate place on the screen. Don’t throw away any of the ideas contained in your notes since they might come in handy, even if you don’t see how at the moment. As you continue to type in the notes, arrange them under whatever topics and subtopics seem relevant to you, generating these labels as you go along and thereby actually beginning your analysis, but disguising it as the less serious and therefore less scary job of just copying your notes. This more or less “analyzes” your scattered ideas, putting the ones that seem to go together under the same heading in your growing outline. “Seem to go together?” Yes, and don’t look too closely, for the moment, for what they have in common. Follow your intuition." Chapter 4: EDITING BY EAR

 
imagining somebody else reading or experiencing our work

"[This] suggests that they do not work by consulting a set of rules or criteria. Rather, they respond as they imagine others might respond, and construct those imaginings from their repeated experiences of hearing people apply the undefined terms in concrete situations. (Becker 1982a, 199–200)"

 
wind out of sails

"Take the common expression, “to take the wind out of someone’s sails.” I had used that, read it, and heard it for years, but it never meant any more to me than that you somehow deflated the person you did it to. Then I learned to sail. In sailing races, your opponents try to come between you and the wind, so that their sail keeps the wind from hitting yours. When they do that successfully, your sails, full of wind and pushing you along briskly a moment before, suddenly begin to flap emptily. The hull’s friction in the water, now that no wind is pushing to counteract it, brings the boat to a sudden halt. The metaphor came to life for me, recalling an irritating experience in all its fullness. But the metaphor means little or nothing to people who haven’t had that experience." Chapter 8: TERRORIZED BY THE LITERATURE

 
you cannot choose method or theory

"Students (and other scholars/writers) often, as I said earlier, talk about “using” this or that theoretical approach—“I think I’ll use Durkheim”—as though they had a free choice of theories. In fact, by the time they begin to write about their research, they have made many seemingly unimportant choices of details that have foreclosed their choice of a theoretical approach. They decided what questions to investigate. They picked a way of gathering information. They chose between a variety of minor technical and procedural alternatives: who to interview, how to code their data, when to stop, what statistical tests (if any) to use. As they made these choices from day to day, they increasingly committed themselves to one way of thinking rather than other possibilities, more or less firmly answering the theoretical questions they thought were still up for grabs."

 
originality is just a faulty memory

"Students learn that they “must” say something about all the people who have discussed “their” problem before them. No one wants to discover that their carefully nurtured idea was in print before they thought of it (maybe before they were born) and in a place they should have looked. (Or did look and then forgot. Wirth also told us that originality was the product of a faulty memory.)"

 
issues of the classics and also the halo effect

"Stinchcombe also mentions an organizational function of the classics: to symbolize solidarity among people in a field. “It is the fact that we have all read these classics, or at least answered preliminary examination questions on them, that binds us together into an intellectual community.” He worries about this function, thinking that it leads us to admire work that time may have shown to be wrong (as, he says, Whitney Pope showed that Durkheim was wrong about suicide): “What is destructive about admiration of the classics, then, is the halo effect, the belief that because a book or article is useful for one purpose, it must have all the virtues."

 
Walter Benjamin collages

"From the Goethe essay on, quotations are at the center of every work of Benjamin’s. This very fact distinguishes his writings from scholarly works of all kinds in which it is the function of quotations to verify and document opinions, wherefore they can safely be relegated to the Notes. . . . The main work [for Benjamin] consisted in tearing fragments out of their context and arranging them afresh in such a way that they illustrated one another and were able to prove their raison d’etre in a free-floating state, as it were. It definitely was a sort of surrealistic montage. (Arendt 1969, 47)"

 
ideological hegemony

"The literature has the advantage of what is sometimes called ideological hegemony over you. If its authors own the territory, their approach to it seems as natural and reasonable as your new and different approach seems strange and unreasonable. Their ideology controls how readers think about the topic. As a result, you have to explain why you haven’t asked those questions and gotten those answers. Proponents of the dominant argument don’t have to explain their failure to look at things your way."

 
trapped in time and space... is that what an LLM does?

"don’t know how people can tell when they are letting the literature deform their argument. It’s the classic dilemma of being trapped in the categories of your time and place. What you can do is recognize the dominant ideology (as I did at the time with respect to drug use), look for its ideological component, and try to find a more neutral scientific stance toward the problem. You know you are on the right track when people tell you you’re on the wrong track."

 
use the literature, dont let it use you

"It may take a long time to find out that this has happened to you, if you find out at all. I only saw my mistake about the marijuana study years later when I extended the argument far beyond where I had originally stopped (see the discussion in Becker 2014, 61–93). Use the literature, don’t let it use you." Chapter 9: WRITING WITH COMPUTERS, THEN AND NOW

 
as soon as a metric is accepted it ceases to be a good metric

"However. . . . This is where Campbell’s Law (Donald Campbell 1979) creates a highly relevant obstacle to any such simple solution. Here is the complete statement of Campbell’s wonderful insight: The more any quantitative social indicator is used for social decision-making, the more subject it will be to corruption pressures and the more apt it will be to distort and corrupt the social processes it is intended to monitor."

 
longer titles dont help

"Here’s Moody’s final judgment: “These data suggest no relation between the number of words in the title and achieved visibility. The coefficient for citations never approaches statistical significance and is negative, not positive. These findings suggest that long titles are not effectively capturing reader’s attention.” In other words, solid evidence triumphs over the wishful thinking of anxious (or maybe just cynical) authors. So the coming of the computers has been a mixed blessing." Chapter 10: A FINAL WORD

 
agreed...

"Some people have thought my suggestions for seemingly endless rewriting unrealistic or needlessly heroic. No one has that much time, they say. How can you stand to work so hard? That shows a great misunderstanding. No one has done the careful studies that would prove it, but I’m convinced that scholars who write as I’ve suggested take less time to do seven or eight drafts than other people spend on one. They have no special gift. It’s just the difference between trying to get it right in your head the first time and then, and only then, doing it on paper or a computer monitor and fixing up little things as you go along. Nor are such writers unusually able to bear anxiety. Instead of bearing it, they avoid it by first doing only what is easy to do and moving in small steps from that to something marginally harder. The easier cleaning-up steps reduce the punch of the real anxiety producers."

Bradley, A. (2008). Derrida's Of Grammatology: An Edinburgh Philosophical Guide. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.    
Added by: alexb44   Last edited by: alexb44 03/11/2026, 02:27
western metaphysics through writing

"Derrida argues that ‘grammatology’ offers us an insight into a much bigger set of philosophical assumptions, namely, the ‘metaphysics of presence [la métaphysique de la présence]’ (p. 49/71). What exactly does this forbidding term mean? It is generally understood that ‘metaphysics’ is the name for a specific branch of philosophy that seeks to locate an ultimate ground, essence or foundation of reality that lies beyond the physical or empirical world: the classic example of such a position would be Plato’s idealism which argues that our world is merely the imitation of a pre-existing world of permanent, unchanging Ideas or Forms. However, Derrida has a much more ambitious understanding of ‘metaphysics’ that encompasses the entire history of western philosophy from Plato to the present day. For Derrida, the western philosophical tradition in its entirety can be described as ‘metaphysical’ in the sense that it all seeks to establish an essential foundation for reality and, in his view, that foundation is something called ‘presence’. If western philosophy has developed in many different directions over the last 2,500 years, what all these movements have in common is an attempt to posit a full or pure ‘presence’ as the supreme value by which all reality can be judged. From the spatial presence of something we can see, hear or touch, through the temporal presence of the ‘here and now’ in which we live, up to and including the absence of some presence that has been lost (such as an Edenic state of nature) or which may be achieved in the future (such as the return of God), western thought consistently comes to the same conclusion: what is most real, true or important is what is most present. In Derrida’s view, the ‘metaphysics of presence’ historically operates by erecting a series of binary oppositions between concepts, values or terms where, in each case, one concept is identified as the bearer of presence itself whereas the other is identified with the falling away, or loss of, that presence: Introduction 7 the transcendental is privileged as more ‘present’ than the empirical, the ideal is championed over the material, the soul over the body, the masculine over the feminine and so on ad infinitum"

 
everything goes through a "delay". nothing is ever simply there

"whatever we perceive or experience as fully ‘present’ – the sound of my own voice, the wooden desk that I can touch in front of me, the thoughts that are running through my head while I read or write, even the ‘here and now’ of space and time in which I exist – is actually shot through with an infinite, and almost imperceptible, number of differences, delays or spaces. Quite simply, Derrida argues that every apparently pure, stable or self-identical presence is nothing more than an effect generated by a prior series of differences: nothing is ever purely or simply ‘there’."

 
everything stands in contrast

"Derrida shows that the supposedly primary, dominant or superior value implicitly relies on the supposedly secondary, different or inferior value in order to achieve the presence that it should achieve all by itself: the masculine depends upon the feminine in order to define its own identity in the first place. What form does this process take in the Grammatology?"

 
logo-centrism

"For Derrida, Of Grammatology takes the form of an extended analysis of the metaphysical opposition between speech and writing. It focuses on what the philosopher takes to be a defining form of what we have called the metaphysical search for ‘presence’: logocentrism (p. 3/11). According to the etymology of the term, ‘logocentrism’ 8 Derrida’s Of Grammatology signifies the philosophical attempt to find what the Ancient Greeks called the logos: a term which can be literally translated as ‘word’ but also carries within it the larger sense of ‘logic’, ‘reason’ or ‘meaning’."

 
agree. everything is both ethnocentric and anthropocentric

"logocentrism might even be described as the most ‘original and powerful ethnocentrism’, he writes in the ‘Exergue’, because it violently privileges and imposes the values of western culture over all others (p. 3/12)."

 
writing is language

"Derrida challenges the logocentric attempt to champion speech over writing by arguing that all language – whether spoken or written – might be described as ‘writing’: writing is another name for language itself."

 
we cannot go beyond the metaphysical limitations of our writing/language

"Derrida does not propose that we can ever simply overcome logocentric or metaphysical assumptions. We cannot simply establish some new, more accurate theory or system of knowledge to replace the metaphysics of presence ( Positions, p. 12). If Derrida’s work is a thoroughgoing interrogation of metaphysics, the fact remains that he is deeply sceptical of any attempt to get ‘beyond’ it for the very simple reason that we have no way of thinking, talking or writing that is not dominated by the metaphysical tradition: ‘[w]e have no language – no syntax and no lexicon – which is foreign to this history’ he writes in a contemporaneous essay.3 To reject metaphysics tout court, in other words, is to reject language and thought itself."

 
the movements of deconstruction

"‘The movements of deconstruction do not destroy structures from the outside. They are not possible and effective, nor can they take accurate aim, except by inhabiting those structures’ ( Grammatology, p. 24/39)."

 
As Stiegler experienced in prison. No text can be read the same way twice

"For Derrida, all language – whether spoken or written – exists in an irreducible state of mediation: we cannot simply return to the animating intentions, consciousness or ‘presence’ of the user, speaker or author. From the moment we begin to speak or write, in other words, we set in motion a complex linguistic machine that has a ‘life’ quite independent of our own: what we call Of Grammatology is a cog in that mechanism. If we cannot return to the true, original or intended meaning of Derrida’s text, this means that there can be no end to the process of reading, analysing and interpreting it: the meaning of the text does not lie behind us in some distant past, in other words, but in front of us, in the future, as something that is yet to be decided. In all these senses, I think the task of reading Derrida’s Of Grammatology can only be an endless one, but let us at least begin." Chapter 1: Historical Context

 
anti-metaphysical philisophy as ground for derrida. but cannot ever go beyond it

"If the essential metaphysical question still remained the same – what is? – the answer changed from ‘the ideal’, ‘substance’ or ‘god’ to the ‘thinking or knowing subject’. For the seventeenth-century rationalist philosopher Descartes, the ego cogito or thinking subject provided the only firm foundation upon which knowledge could be grounded and this position is pursued and refined in different ways by such figures as Kant and Husserl.2 The last decades of the nineteenth century, however, saw the emergence of a new, more radical critique of metaphysics in the work of such seminal figures as Marx, Nietzsche and Freud. This so-called ‘hermeneutics of suspicion’ is what lays the groundwork for Derrida’s own attempt to question the grounding assumptions of western metaphysics ( Writing and Difference, p. 280). In Derrida’s own view, deconstruction is heavily indebted to this larger tradition of ‘anti-metaphysical philosophy’ but, as we will see, his philosophy remains deeply sceptical about the possibility of ever simply getting ‘beyond’ metaphysics."

 
Marx - consciousness comes from life, it is everything we do. labour, work...

"Karl Marx sees all our Historical Context 17 metaphysical ideas about reality as nothing more than imaginary expressions of the processes of life, nature and history. Quite simply, our view of reality is upside-down: we must understand consciousness from the perspective of life, rather than life from the perspective of consciousness.3 According to Marx’s philosophy of historical materialism, what defines ‘life’ in this case is not biology but history: being alive is not something we are so much as something we do, the way in which we work or labour, how we organise our existence socially, materially and economically ( German Ideology, p. 48)."

 
ascetic ideal. truth is what we make ir, according to Nietszche

"Friedrich Nietzsche famously sees the production of metaphysical belief systems as an attempt to repress the dynamic processes of life itself: the ‘other’ world of metaphysics is the product of this world rather than its cause or foundation. Proposing 18 Derrida’s Of Grammatology what he calls a ‘genealogy’ of metaphysics, Nietzsche shows how apparently timeless, unconditioned values arise out of the very history they are supposed to explain in the first place. Quite simply, we must see concepts like ‘truth’, ‘being’ or ‘consciousness’ less as descriptions of ‘what is’ and more as misleading linguistic abstractions of a flux of historical, physiological and affective forces. For Nietzsche, metaphysics is the product of what he calls an ‘ascetic ideal’ that leads human beings to renounce ‘this world, our world’ in favour of ‘ another world’.6 Yet, it is impossible to reach this other world because it never existed in the first place and so humanity falls back into ‘ ressentiment’: a sense of permanent guilt that finds its apex in the Christian view of human existence as ‘fallen’. What lies beneath the metaphysical ‘will to truth’ of the ascetic ideal is the ‘will to power’: the capacity to liberate ourselves from the pursuit of the timeless other world of ‘truth’, and affirm our place within, and as a product of, the endlessly creative becoming of this world."

 
the consciouss is a combination of a bunch of subconsciouss stuff all at once - Stiegler also believes this?

"Sigmund Freud’s pyschoanalysis intensifies this critique of the rational thinking or knowing subject which had become the last refuge of metaphysics in modernity: psychoanalysis ‘put[s] consciousness into question in its assured certainty of itself ’ Derrida writes ( Margins, p. 17). To Freud’s way of thinking, what we call the rational or self-conscious ‘I’ is the meeting point of a range of different, competing and often unconscious forces, desires or principles: ‘consciousness may be, not the most universal attribute of human processes, but only a particular fraction of them’.8 What is ground-breaking about psychoanalysis for Derrida is precisely this insight into how apparently simple, identical and present points of origin – such as the consciousness of the subject – are actually the product of an originary and unthought network of differences: ‘The putting into question of the authority of consciousness is first and always differential’ ( Margins, p. 18)."

 
metaphysics of the unconsciuss a new source of truth

"The psychoanalytic system may well call into question the self-presence of consciousness but it does so at the cost of turning the unconscious into a ‘hidden, virtual, or potential self-presence’. This means that Freud risks establishing a metaphysics of the unconscious whereby our drives and instincts become a new metaphysical basis for truth (pp. 20–1)."

 
metaphysics inescapable

"The crucial thing to grasp about Derrida’s readings of the history of philosophy, in other words, is that he is neither seeking to score points off metaphysics itself (as if anyone who believed in it were stupid or erroneous), nor to establish some new anti-metaphysical system (which would somehow avoid, or correct, the errors of its predecessor), so much as articulating this larger, and more complex, dilemma. There is an unavoidable sense in which every attempt to overcome metaphysics cannot help but repeat the language, discourse and assumptions of metaphysics, Derrida argues, because there is quite simply no other vocabulary available to us ( Positions, p. 12). This is why Derrida admits right from the outset of his work that his own critique of metaphysics must necessarily work within the very system of ideas it wishes to contest even, at the risk of simply replicating it ( Grammatology, p. 24/39)."

 
on dasein

"The Being of entities “is” not itself an entity’.10 To introduce the thesis of his seminal work Being and Time, Heidegger argues that the basic question ‘What is Being?’ has been largely forgotten by western philosophy because the latter focuses exclusively on beings or entities ( Being and Time, p. 2). Heidegger seeks to recuperate the meaning of Being itself by focusing on a particular kind of being and the one he chooses is human being or, as he famously calls it, Dasein (‘there-being’). For Heidegger, what defines Dasein is that it is not a being or entity that exists in time (like a rock or an animal) so much as a being who exists as time, whose being is essentially temporal: we are quite literally nothing other than the accumulation of our past experiences, on the one hand, and what we have the potential to ‘project’ out of those experiences into the future, on the other."

 
writing empty vessel

"For Derrida, both traditions par-ticipate in the championing of speech as the true bearer of presence and the repression or marginalisation of writing as a base or empty vessel that is the logocentric gesture par excellence."

 
consciousness always intentional

"It focuses on the essence of these particular ‘intuitions’, in other words, what your experience of them says about the way in which consciousness works more generally. According to Husserl, the defining characteristic of consciousness is that it is intentional, by which he means that it is always directed towards objects. To put it simply: consciousness is not an empty box into which objects are subsequently placed, but always the consciousness of some object."

 
husserl summary

"For Husserl, intentionality contains two, intrinsically linked, sides: the noesis, or intentional act of consciousness that is directed towards an object, and the object, or noema, towards which that act is directed. If this argument goes some way towards breaking down the subject/object dualism that has plagued philosophy since Descartes, it is important to bear in mind that Husserl’s phenomenology remains at all times a theory of consciousness: what concerns him is purely that which presents itself to our conscious experience – a phenomenon – and he is careful not to make any presumptions about what may or may not lie behind that appearance. The intentional act can only be understood as what it is if Historical Context 25 we suspend or ‘bracket’ off – the key term Husserl uses here is ‘ epoché’ – all our everyday assumptions about the empirical existence of external objects (what he calls the ‘natural attitude’), together with any prior philosophical assumptions or prejudices we might have about essence, existence or substance. This ‘transcendental’ attempt to clarify the pure or essential structures of consciousness by rigorously suspending or ‘reducing’ any presumption of the existence of the empirical world is increasingly criticised by Husserl’s successors. In the view of later figures like Heidegger, Levinas and Ricoeur, Husserl’s focus on the purity of consciousness risks becoming too abstract and theoretical in approach: phenomenology must take account of the context – linguistic, existential, ethical – in which consciousness is embedded."

 
communication through spoken word is indicative, beause the other person doesnt experencing what we experiencing directly

"Second, though, Derrida observes that Husserl goes on to associate expression with speech and indication with writing: speech is expressive because it necessarily entails the presence of the speaker, whereas writing is indicative because the writer is absent and substituted by a graphic inscription or mark. Unfortunately, though, things are not quite this simple because, as Derrida shows, the boundary between expression and indication, speech and writing and, more generally, presence and absence, constantly needs to be re-drawn. Straightaway, Husserl is forced to concede that not all s peech is expressive: when we speak in order to communicate with someone else, our 26 Derrida’s Of Grammatology words merely indicate our inner experience for the other person because, of course, they are not directly experiencing what we are experiencing."

 
immediately present

"It is Husserl’s contention that objects are immediately present to consciousness in both the spatial and the temporal senses of the word. When I ‘intend’ a certain object, it is present here and now to my consciousness: ‘[f]or the acts in question are themselves experienced by us at that very moment in the blink of an eye [ im selben Augenblick]’ ( Logical Investigations, p. 280). Once again, however, Derrida uses an example from Husserl’s own phenomenology – in this case his lectures on internal time consciousness – to show that the present moment in which perception takes place is in fact anything but ‘present’. To clarify what might seem at face value to be a paradoxical argument, Derrida argues that what we perceive as the Historical Context 27 ‘now’ or present moment is in fact a synthesis or composite of memory and expectation, retention and protention. Derrida notes how Husserl himself shows us in The Phenomenology of Internal Time Consciousness that when we listen to a piece of music we retain the memory of the note just played, we hear the note currently being played, and anticipate the next note in the sequence, all at once. For Husserl, in other words, retention – the memory of what has just passed – is the ‘tail’ that always follows the ‘comet’ of primary impression.13 If perception of the present is thus shot through with absence – what has just past and what is about to come – then Husserl’s theory of consciousness is once again shown to be always and already conditioned by the kind of mediation that he brackets off as external or inessential to his phenomenology. Just as the space of consciousness is mediated by things that are not fully present – linguistic signs – so the time of consciousness is structured by what is temporally absent: the past and the future. In this sense, Husserl’s metaphysics of ‘presence’ is once again forced to rely on the very thing it seeks to exclude: ‘This alterity is in fact the very condition for presence’ ( Speech and Phenomena, p. 65)."

 
Saussure. words have meaning only in context

"Ferdinand de Saussure (1857–1913) was a linguist but is now commonly held to be the ‘father’ of the modern movement called structuralism. He focused his research less on particular units of language – what he calls ‘ parole’ or speech – so much as on the underlying system of language ( langue) in which those units exist. He famously argues that individual units of language acquire meaning from their relative position within the linguistic system as a whole: a word like ‘cat’, for example, has no meaning outside the system of the English language."

 
everything in context, contrast

"For Saussure and his followers, in other words, consciousness is always mediated through a prior network of signs, concepts, and values which enable us to make sense of our experience and, in this respect, at least, it would seem to confirm Derrida’s own critique of phenomenology. More generally, as we will see in Part 2, structuralism institutes a differential and relational theory of meaning that will be an enormous influence upon Derridaean deconstruction. Just as a single chess piece only makes sense in the context of the other pieces on the board, so no individual unit within a network has meaning in itself but rather achieves meaning in relation to all the other units within the system."

 
what structures the search for structuralism?

"Derrida begins this essay by effectively seeking to turn the tables on structuralism itself: what, he asks, structures the search for structures of language, culture and society? As we have already begun to see, his answer to this question is that structuralism is characterised by the attempt to identify a fixed point or centre at the heart of every structure ( Writing and Difference, p. 278)."

 
everything has a place except the center

"For Derrida, then, it becomes clear that structuralism is curiously self-exempting: everything has a structure – a relative place within the play of the system – except the centre of the structure itself where that play comes to a stop (p. 279)."

 
cant run from metaphysics. new directions simply ignire them, but not dealing with them is not sctually avoiding them

"Quite simply, structuralism’s attempt to just stop doing philosophy and begin again with something more ‘scientific’ and ‘objective’ like anthropology, linguistics or history leaves its own deepest metaphysical assumptions unquestioned. If structuralism continually throws up new scientific methodologies – Saussure’s linguistics, Lévi-Strauss’s ethnography, Michel Foucault’s archaeology or Pierre Bourdieu’s sociology – in order to get around old metaphysical problems, Derrida argues that all these supposedly original approaches actually presuppose some of the most ancient philosophical oppositions imaginable: speech and writing, nature and culture, the transcendental and the empirical, and so on."

 
levi-strauss caught

"for all his scientific credentials – Lévi-Strauss’s structuralist anthropology remains ‘caught . . . within the metaphysics – logocentrism – which at the same time [he] claims rather precipitately to have “gone beyond” ’ ( Grammatology, p. 99/148): Lévi-Strauss, like Husserl before him, takes a more or less arbitrary decision that truth will equal presence which, in turn, will be equated with speech."

 
bought by repressing writing, mediation, difference

"For Derrida, in other words, what Lévi-Strauss’s structuralism teaches us is that even the most rigorous disciplines outside the province of philosophy remain caught within the foundational incoherence of the metaphysics of presence because, once again, their sponsorship of truth, presence and speech is bought and paid for by the repression of mediation, difference, writing. In this way, Derrida’s critique of metaphysics inevitably takes us beyond the domain of structuralism as well as phenomenology."

 
there is a rich historicity in even "primordial" terms like Being - they stand on a tradition

"Derrida’s critique of metaphysics is in many ways an attempt to reveal what we might call the radical historicity of the present. As he consistently argues, what appear to be timeless or natural ideas – ‘being’, ‘truth’ etc. – are actually anything but. Yet, this argument also applies to the philosophical idea of ‘history’ itself, our very understanding of what history is and how it works."

 
duh. history is written by victors, as interpreted by them, as they would like the future to see them. it is understood by the future as something understood through the lens of the future, a future full of historicity as it's been interpreted through our changing views over time

"If what we understand as ‘history’ depends upon a metaphysics of presence, Derrida’s aim is once again to show how that idea of history is itself a historical construction: it cannot be taken as truth. Finally, then, Derrida’s critique of the philosophical concept of ‘history’ seeks to do what he does to any other metaphysical idea, namely, to reveal the open-ended network of differences on which it resides: no historical moment, body of thought, epoch or tradition, is ever wholly at one with itself because it inevitably contains the traces of what precedes and follows it. In Derrida’s hands, what we might call the metaphysical concept of history – where a succession of present moments are strung together like pearls on a neck-lace – begins to unravel into a more complex, plural or differential set of relations between past, present and future: ‘there is not one single history, a general history, but rather histories’ (p. 58" Chapter 2: A Guide to the Text

 
everything is contaminated as writing - language IS writing

"Finally, and most importantly, Derrida will propose that the metaphysical or logocentric commitment to speech depends upon a foundational contradiction or tension: all language – both speech and writing – is characterised by the essential mediation that metaphysics historically assigns to ‘writing’ alone. If the guarantee of truth – speech – is already contaminated with ‘writing’, we will also begin to see that this has important implications for our concept of a pure and unmediated ‘presence’ itself: we cannot gain access to a presence – a ‘there’ – that exists wholly independently of linguistic mediation. For Derrida, as 42 Derrida’s Of Grammatology we will now see, the theory of the linguistic sign represents a privileged symptom of this entire problematic: it is the sign – more than anything else – that is the site of his questioning of logocentrism. What, then, is Derrida’s argument?"

 
deconstruction

"To introduce his own reading of logocentrism, Derrida somewhat mysteriously says that what is required is ‘not the demolition, but the de-sedimentation, the deconstruction’ of the logos’ (p. 10/21)."

 
deconstruction then aims to understand how the text came about - what made it so. in this sense anything spoken is equally spoken for a deeper reason. the natural condition of our feelings for instance depend on what is considered natural. if tech is natural, what tech? Turkle text would say otherwise, as would i... but even the current human condition is far from its initial natural state, as witnessed also by Ong... speech changed a lot over time, probably also during the time until literacy

"For Derrida, what deconstruction attempts to do is to articulate the – often hidden or repressed – conditions according to which it is possible for any structure to be constituted in the first place. In Derrida’s own words, deconstruction signifies the ‘undoing, decomposing and de-sedimenting of structures’ in order to ‘understand how an “ensemble” was constituted and to reconstruct it to this end’."

 
but yet the de-constructiion is done by someone, with their understanding of the text in question, so isnt it more like me + author

"It is also important to stress that ‘deconstruction’ is not a new theory, technique or methodology that we can simply apply to particular texts in the way that we might, for example, do a Marxist or a Freudian ‘reading’ of a novel. As we have already begun to see by looking at the way in which Derrida reads Husserl and Lévi-Strauss, deconstruction is not something we do to a text from the ‘outside’, so to speak, so much as something that we reveal about the way in which any text is internally constructed. If Derrida’s reading of the privileged texts of logocentrism has a purpose, it is not to establish some superior position of knowledge or authority so much as to tease out the immanent contradictions within the texts themselves: Husserl is criticised by none other than Husserl and Lévi-Strauss by no one but Lévi-Strauss."

 
but yet individuals possess differt readings? does this mean that while deconstruction is always already taking place, would it not stop to be so without humans? as such some agency in this equation must lie with us

"For Derrida, then, the process of reading is not a question of actively ‘deconstructing’ logocentrism so much as showing that the metaphysics of presence is already in a process of what we might call ‘self-deconstruction’ insofar as it has a ‘self ’ at all: it has no full or ‘present’ ground or foundation on which to base itself and so it exists in a permanent state of instability or contingency."

 
aristotle - any sign belongs to some mental idea

"It establishes an absolutely fundamental point about the sign that will endure all the way up to the present day: a sign is always a sign or re-presentation of some pre-existing idea or mental experience."

 
writi is a sign of a sign according to aristotle. derrida believes spoken words are no different

"If speech directly signifies the ideas or intentions of the person speaking, in other words, writing only has a second-hand relation to thought because it is nothing more than a sign of a sign. The written signifier is merely the sign of the spoken signifier, in other words, whereas the spoken signifier is the sign of the signified idea or thought"

 
whether the pure presence lies with god or with speaker, the sign remains theological

"If Saussure and other modern linguists obviously dispense with any belief in a creator god lying behind the sign, Derrida has little difficulty in showing that they still retain a residually theological investment in what he calls a ‘transcendental signified’ – an ultimate presence – which anchors all meaning in itself: the presence of God is merely replaced by the presence of the speaker, of his or her thoughts and feelings, and so on. In this sense, Derrida argues that the age of the sign is essentially theological: ‘the sign and divinity have the same place and time of birth’ (p. 14/25)."

 
all signs are characterised by the inescapable means of the metaphysical as a state of mediation

"However, we will see later on that all signs are characterised by this state of mediation – which makes it impossible for them to directly relate to a ‘present’ meaning or signified – and so what logocentrism attributes to ‘writing’ actually describes the state of language as such."

 
it is the becoming aware of this condition that allows closing of thebook - but deconstruction is still infinite. stage of destruction,name is deceptive

"For Derrida, as we will see in the next section, every signifier can be seen as a mere ‘a signifier of a signifier’ – to quote the famous logocentric dismissal of writing – as opposed to something that relates directly to a present signified: what we call ‘writing’ is another name 50 Derrida’s Of Grammatology for the original condition of language as a whole (p. 7/16). Finally, then, it becomes clear that what enables us to ‘close the book’ on logocentrism is this recognition of the inescapably mediated status of all signs: we cannot gain access to a full or present signified, meaning or logos. The ‘death’ of the civilisation of the book, then, signifies the growing awareness that writing cannot be traced back to a pure or unmediated presence, in the way that we can trace the words of a book back to the author who wrote them. This new concept of writing, and indeed language as a whole, has been emerging for a long time, Derrida argues, but it is now beginning to manifest itself in the form of a series of contemporary developments in post-war philosophy, science and thought (p. 6/15–16). Enter grammatology."

 
heidegger - language speaks man, insofar as it calls out from something within the dasein (things that constitute the world of dasein)

"On the contrary, language is a defining condition of everything that we understand as constituting the sphere of the human: consciousness, thought, expression, culture.6 Martin Heidegger, for instance, famously argues that it is language that ‘speaks’ man – rather than the other way around – in the sense that it names or calls into existence the things that constitute the world of Dasein.7 Now, this concept of language as something that does not merely describe the world, but actively constructs the way in which we experience it, is intensified by the structuralist revolution."

 
language puts things into focus for Saussure

"For Ferdinand de Saussure, linguistic signs give shape and clarity to what would otherwise be a shadowy flux of impressions in the same way that a pair of glasses gives definition to the sight of a myopic person: it is only because I have the sign of a ‘table’ – both the signifier and the idea or concept signified by it – that I am able to make sense of the real, actual object in front of me. If Saussure is concerned with how language mediates or constructs our experience of the real world, his structuralist successors go on to extend his principles from language to reality itself: our engagement with the real world itself – the world that supposedly lies beyond language – is structured according to models of signification drawn from Saussure’s linguistics."

 
as writing becomes increasingly primary, so will its effects on us be more pronounced. it has already had psychosocial effects. chatbots alter how we write, what does that mean for us? if knowledge becomes surface level, as it increasingly has in education over the past twenty years, then what knowledge mesns is re-written, and the consequences are massive

"For Derrida, however, this ‘linguistic’ turn is in the process of being superseded by what we might call a ‘scriptural’ turn. It is now writing, and not language in general, that has become the dominant means of explaining consciousness, culture, the psyche and so on: ‘[n]ow we tend to say “writing” for all that and more’ (p. 9/19)."

 
writing was ways already there, no origin. only in the Derridaean sense - writing signs of course different

"Derrida’s concept of an ‘originary writing’ is not an attempt to establish a new point of origin – as if it would be plausible to say that writing really did evolve before speech – but a way of calling into question the very idea of an origin, an absolute beginning, a pure historical, theological or philosophical point of ‘presence’ to which everything can be traced back."

 
writing makes science possible

"writing cannot be the object of a science, Derrida argues, because it is what makes scientific study possible in the first place. Why is this? For Derrida, as we saw in our discussion of Husserl, writing is the sole means by which we can record, preserve and transmit our thoughts and thus establish something as ‘truth’, ‘knowledge’ or ‘objectivity’ in the first place: the written text is what enables the objects of geometry to transcend the mind of the 58 Derrida’s Of Grammatology first geometers, for instance, and become universal objects for everyone"

 
signifier snd signified linked together, like two sides of a piece of paper

"For Saussure, as we will see, the signifier and the signified – the physical mark and the concept it refers to – are inextricably linked to one another like two sides of the same sheet of paper:"

 
in this sense, llms do not possess language like that of humans, but something else.

"According to Saussure’s structure-based approach, language is not a nomenclature, that is, a series of names for pre-existing objects in the outside world. On the contrary, it is a system that acquires meaning through its own internal structure and relations."

 
its arbitrary. no natural reason a cat is called a cat

"To introduce another important point, however, Saussure argues that the relation between any given signifier and signified is arbitrary. It is motivated by tradition or convention, in other words, rather than by any perceived ‘natural resemblance’ between sound and concept. If I use the sound ‘cat’ to refer to the concept of a cat, it is not because there is any natural relation between this particular signifier and signified but rather because it is accepted that the two go together within the conventions of the English language: the convention is very different in the French and Italian languages, for instance, where other signifiers (‘chat’ or ‘gatto’) relate to the signified."

 
saussure. any signs acquires meaning through difference

"Finally, and most importantly, however, Saussure also argues that any linguistic sign only acquires its meaning through its difference from other linguistic signs rather than through any ‘positive’ value it might possess in itself. The meaning of any sign is determined by its difference – both phonic and conceptual – from other signs within the system. This complex linguistic system – arbitrary, conventional and differential – is the basis for our experience of the world outside language."

 
saussure worry about writing becoming primary. his worried might be misplaced, but there are other concerns, namely lack of sociality, etc.

"Intriguingly, he is especially worried that writing may displace speech from its position at the centre of language and reverse the natural order of the spoken and the written word. What concerns him is that the written word – because it seems to represent a more durable, lasting mode of signification than speech – will gradually come to be seen as representative of language as a whole. Now, this would be an absolute disaster, in his view, because writing mediates, or even breaks, what he sees as the ‘natural bond’ between sound and sense. If writing is taken to represent language as whole, Saussure predicts, all sorts of apocalyptic catastrophes will ensue. The spelling of a word will come to influence, and even modify, the way in which that word is said, he says, and even in his own time this is leading to terrible mispronunciations. This scenario will not strike many readers as particularly awful though – is mispronunciation really such a disaster"

 
signs contain traces of other signs, which me visible differences

"The idea or phonic substance that a sign contains is of less importance than the other signs that surround it. ( Course, pp. 117–18) What exactly is Saussure saying here? If any one sign has meaning, it is not because it possesses any content or substance in itself but because it differs – both phonically and conceptually – from other signs within the linguistic system. The sign ‘cat’ (regardless of whether we see it from the perspective of the sound or the concept) exists within a prior network of relations to other signs (‘hat’, ‘bat’ and so on). There is a paradoxical sense in which the idea of a singular or unique sign is, then, something of a contradiction-in-terms. This is because any apparently singular, ‘present’ and independent sign necessarily contains within it the traces of other signs within the system against which it is to be defined. In Derrida’s view, as we will A Guide to the Text 67 see in a moment, this theory has radical implications for the logocentric theory of the sign."

 
language as a species of writing

"The fact is that every signifier might best be described as a ‘signifier of a signifier’ because, according to Saussure’s own theory, every sign works by referring to other signs within the system rather than to some positive content of its own. There is an important sense, then, in which the lowly position of writing – inferior, derivative, always at one step removed from the main action – accurately describes the position of language as a whole. This means that writing is not so much ‘comparable’ to language as the other way around: language might even be described as a species of writing (p. 52/75)."

 
arche-writing

"Derrida’s contention is that the position historically attributed to ‘writing’ in western culture actually describes the condition of all language whatsoever: what is called ‘writing’ names the framework ‘common to all systems of signification’ (p. 46/68) whether they be spoken, written, drawn, electronically recorded or transmitted. Indeed, he goes to great pains to distinguish this ‘originary’ concept of writing from what he calls the ‘vulgar’ or conventional idea of writing as a set of empirical marks, letters or inscriptions (p. 46/68)."

 
originary trace

"To put it simply, what Derrida calls the originary trace represents his most systematic attempt to articulate this central point in the Grammatology: mediation goes all the way down."

 
originary trace as linked to saussure

"To recall Saussure’s argument, linguistic signs are not constituted by any intrinsic phonic or conceptual substance – a particular sound or idea that is inherent to that sign itself – but by their difference from other signs in the system. If every sign in the system obtains its identity through its difference from all the other signs, then this means every sign is intrinsically marked by what it is not. Every sign must retain the traces of the other signs against which it is to be defined, in other words, in order to have any meaning at all."

 
the pure trace is differance

"‘ the (pure) trace’ he declares, is différance [ la trace (pure) et la différance]’ (p. 62/92)."

 
on Differance

"says this: ‘[w]e shall designate by the term différance the movement by which any language, or any code, any system of reference in general, becomes “historically” constituted as a fabric of differences’ (p. 141)."

 
originsry trace shows that signs first refer to other signs, meaning no such thing as a pure thought or concept

"However, what the originary trace shows us is that every sign first refers to other signs, as opposed to some ‘present’ concept that is not itself a sign. We can see, then, that the originary trace throws the whole logocentric concept of the sign into crisis by proposing that we never arrive at a simple or unmediated meaning: nothing is unmediated. For Derrida, every signifier relates to other signifiers that surround it in space and time and so we can never reach a pure thought or concept – a signified – that exists in and of itself independently of all signifiers: what is supposedly beyond language is plunged back into language. If we take a very simple example of this, it becomes much clearer: every time we look up a word in the dictionary – ‘love’, for example – what we find is not the meaning of that word but merely other words that act as synonyms for it (‘love’ means ‘adoration’ or ‘desire’) or even antonyms (‘love’ means the opposite of ‘hate’)."

 
thought is differance, then

"In Derrida’s account, all thought remains caught with the network of spatial and temporal differentiation that is the ‘trace’: ‘ We think only in signs’ (p. 50/73, English in original)."

 
originary trace paradoxical

"According to the same logic, the trace is neither sensible nor intelligible. It is not something that can be recognised by our senses (like a sound or smell), in other words, nor something that can be conceived within our minds (like an idea or concept). On the one hand, we cannot see or hear it because, it is nothing but the difference between spoken or written marks. On the other, we cannot quite think it either 74 Derrida’s Of Grammatology because, once again, the difference between ideas or concepts cannot, strictly speaking, itself be a concept (p. 62/92–3)."

 
interior requires traces of exterior - husserl

"In Derrida’s readings of Husserl, for example, we saw how the supposed purity of our interior consciousness requires the traces of the ‘external’ world (communication, indication, writing) in order to relate to itself in the first place: what is apparently ‘outside’ is already ‘inside’ (p. 44/65)."

 
originary trace already there

"For Derrida, the trace cannot be traced to any point of simple spatial or temporal presence – whether a present that is now past or one that is yet to come – because it is the underlying differential condition of any ‘presence’ whatsoever. In Derrida’s own paradoxical phrase, the originary trace can never be ‘there’ because it is ‘always-already-there [ toujours déjà-lá]’: it both recedes into an infinite past and projects itself into an infinite future (p. 66/97)."

 
trace is origin of meaning

"the logic of metaphysics? In simple terms, the trace is prior to every metaphysical concept because it is the movement of différance – of differing and deferring – that allows them to appear as concepts in the first place: ‘[ t] he trace is in fact the absolute origin of sense in general’ (pp. 62/95)."

 
exceeds "what is?"

"Quite simply, the whole point of the trace is that it is an orginary condition of mediation, synthesis or complexity rather than a present being, thing or entity: ‘[t]he trace is nothing, it is not an entity, it exceeds the question What is?’ (p. 75/110)."

 
no pure origin

"To declare that ‘everything begins with the trace’, then, is not an attempt to posit some new, even more fundamental point of origin, in other words, but to assert that there is no pure, simple or present origin in the first place (p. 65/95). For Derrida, that is to say, any origin is always multiple: what claims to be a singular point of origin must always define itself against something that it is not, dividing itself in at least two, multiplying itself like a cell through a process of infinite differing/deferring"

 
nothing is ever purely present or absent

"What should be opposed and hierarchised terms presuppose one another. To Derrida’s eyes, any value that metaphysics posits as ‘present’ – speech, nature, consciousness – is thus always already spreading or dispersing outwards into a network of traces, differences and mediations: nothing is ever purely present or absent."

 
desire for presence both possible and impossible

"In what is now a A Guide to the Text 77 famous argumentative move, Derrida contends that the originary trace thus places every metaphysics of presence in a curious double-bind: it is both what makes the desire for presence possible in the first place and what makes the fulfilment of that desire impossible."

 
languagee always already a writing

"Now, Lévi-Strauss himself portrays writing as something that arrives to violate a place or moment of pure presence from ‘outside’, but what Derrida is once again going to show is that this foreign body is already intrinsic to language itself: we must articulate the ‘originary violence of a language which is always already a writing’ (p. 106/156)."

 
fall within nature

"all language – whether it be the ‘speech’ of the Nambikwara or the ‘writing’ of Lévi-Strauss himself – is already a species of a more originary and generalised ‘writing’ and this compels him to re-think the Rousseauean mythology of a fall from a prelapsarian utopia. In Derrida’s words, we are not dealing with a fall from nature into culture, peace into violence or speech into writing so much as a fall within nature itself, which is thus revealed to be never quite ‘natural’ in the first place."

 
us and them

"As Derrida argues, what seems like an innocent anecdote actually belongs to an eighteenth-century A Guide to the Text 85 tradition of confessional writing whereby autobiography is the basis for a philosophical reflection upon the relation between nature and society, between an ‘ideal’ society and ‘real’ society or, to put it more bluntly, between ‘us’ and ‘them’ (pp. 113–14/166)."

 
reverse ethnocentrism

"For Derrida, the larger Rousseauean agenda of this narrative is also clear: Lévi-Strauss is not so much seeking to discover the way of life of any particular people but the ideal basis of human society as a whole (p. 115/169–70). In fact, Lévi-Strauss’s anthropology might be suspected of a kind of reverse ethnocentrism: what begins as an almost Marxian critique of attempts to impose western culture on other peoples as if it were a universal standard ends up setting up a thoroughly romanticised version of non-western culture as the ideal by which all humanity is to be judged."

 
peter is different to tom. saussure differential theory of language

"According to Saussure’s differential theory of language – which, as we have seen, heavily influences Lévi-Strauss’s anthropology – a proper name can only be proper if it exists in a relation to other proper names: ‘Peter’ is only meaningful because it is different from ‘Mary’. Now, the upshot of this position is that no name can ever be ‘proper’ in and of itself – in the sense that it refers solely, directly and uniquely, to what it names – and this leads Derrida to speak of the ‘death’ of absolutely proper naming (p. 109/164). To Derrida’s eyes, in other words, it thus becomes possible to speak of an ‘originary’ violence at work in the act of naming because the very structure of language itself violates the supposed propriety, the supposedly unique status, of the proper name: ‘Anterior to the possibility of violence in the current and derivative sense’ he argues, we find ‘the violence of the arche-writing, the violence of difference, of classification, and of 88 Derrida’s Of Grammatology the system of appellations’ (p. 110/162). For"

 
law

"To put it in a word, then, Derrida argues that the second level of violence is the institution of law. However, once again this seems a somewhat strange move to make: law is commonly seen as that which puts an end to violence, that which restores or protects a state of peace, so why see it as representing a new form of violence? Quite simply, the answer is that what we call the ‘law’ can only meet violence with violence. The institution of law by the Nambikwara cannot actually restore an original state of peace in which all proper names are respected, for no such state ever existed, so all it can do is more or less violently suppress the violence of language itself under the guise of ‘justice’ ‘morality’ or ‘society’. This apparent attempt to preserve the so-called ‘proper’ names by forbidding their disclosure is, Derrida argues, thus actually what makes those names proper in the first place. For Derrida, then, it is the identification of, and prohibition against, something called ‘impropriety’ that produces the illusion of a pre-existing state of ‘propriety’. In other words, the institution of law manufactures the very state of original ‘propriety’ it claims to protect: ‘the so-called proper, substitute of the deferred proper, perceived by the social and moral consciousness as the proper’ (p. 112/165)."

 
the violence of writing

"For Derrida, this story reveals that the violence of writing – the network of differences, relations and mediation which interrupts every pure, unique or self-identical meaning – is at work within Nambikwara society long before the advent of writing in the accepted, empirical sense of that term: what Lévi-Strauss persists in calling ‘peace’ is already a state of violence. In the next part of the chapter, Derrida pursues this insight into a reading of another pivotal scene in Tristes tropiques called the ‘writing lesson’."

 
therecis already differance or archewriting which opens up speech

"For Derrida, in other words, an ‘originary’ writing appears well before writing in the narrow sense: it is ‘already in the différance or the arche- writing that opens speech itself ’ (p. 128/186)."

 
levi strauss

"If the epoch of writing is characterised by anything, it is less the advancement of knowledge than the extension of power, domination and segregation through political, economic and administrative elites: the historic function of writing has been to reinforce the power of the few rather than to bring knowledge to the many."

 
grammatology is study of writing

"grammatology, properly understood, is the study of what writing is, when and how it originated, and the ways in which it differs from other forms of communication like speech. For Derrida, the study of writing goes as far back as Plato but, strictly speaking, the science of ‘grammatology’ itself is a more modern one"

 
scientific knowledge contingent on writing... duh

"However, we have already seen in the last chapter that, if anything, the exact opposite is the case. For Derrida, scientific knowledge is contingent upon the invention of writing: any objective or universal truth that remains the same for everyone, everywhere throughout space and time is only possible on the basis of it being preserved, recorded and transmitted through writing."

 
concentrated power contingent on writing

"Derrida agrees that this claim may well be historically incontestable: the invention of writing undoubtedly makes possible both the concentration of power in the hands of a small elite and the delegation, deferment or stockpiling of power. Arguably, Lévi-Strauss has not gone far enough in asserting the relation between writing and power: Derrida would say that even the most primitive agricultural societies begin to possess a kind of arche-writing from the moment they begin to organise themselves in a economic way by deferring immediate consumption of their harvests, putting produce into reserve for the next season and so on (p. 130/190). Moreover, Derrida questions what he sees as an uncritical tendency in Lévi-Strauss’s work to simply equate the establishment of political hierarchies with political exploitation and domination: ‘[p]olitical power [for Lévi-Strauss – AB] can only be the custodian of an unjust power’ (p. 131/191)."

 
peace contains traces of violence. we cannot escape meta physics

"Derrida’s attempt to posit an originary violence within the primitivist utopia occupied by the Nambikwara is not to deny the violence that western colonialism has wreaked upon them, nor to imply a moral equivalence between coloniser and colonised, but it is a way of calling into question the possibility of any pure or absolute moral good: whatever we call ‘peace’, however desirable or justifiable it may be, always contains the traces of violence."

 
no ethics without originary trace, differance through an other

"‘There is no ethics without the presence of the other but also, and consequently, without absence, disimulation, detour, différance, writing’ (p. 140/202)."

 
rousseau. speech natural, writing barrier. writing substitutes thinking

"Rousseau argues that the spoken word naturally expresses our present thoughts whereas the written word erects an unnecessary material barrier between thought and expression. For Rousseau, predictably, writing starts to become dangerous when it does not merely mediate thought but comes to substitute for it: what begins as merely a representation of something ends up becoming confused with the thing itself"

 
Saussuere. confusing signified and signifier

"Now, we have already seen that this is a recurring fear in the history of logocentrism: Saussure, for instance, is just as fearful of a modern, decadent, culture where the signifier is becoming confused with the signified, the representation with the real presence (p. 42/62–3)."

 
fallibikity of speech, rousseau

"In Derrida’s account, then, Rousseau’s theory accomplishes almost the exact opposite of its apparent intention: what is revealed is less the destructive impact of writing than the fallibility of speech."

 
progress is also a result of differance

"This creates a paradoxical situation within Rousseau’s thought whereby his philosophy of education comes into conflict with his political critique of civil society. In other words, the very thing that makes human progress possible – the supplement – is also the beginning of humanity’s fall into the corruption of civil society (p. 147/211)."

 
natural supplement

"In Derrida’s paradoxical terminology, then, we can begin to speak of a ‘natural’ supplement in the same way that we have spoken of an arche-writing or an ‘originary’ trace: ‘the supplement comes naturally to put itself in Nature’s place’ (p. 149/214"

 
makes sense in a society of isolation... people accept the image of what they want, which today is that of the screen

"Quite simply, Derrida argues that Rousseau’s masturbation begins to assume a role that is greater than that of a mere ‘supplement’ to nature: what should be an inferior substitute for a more complete and satisfying form of sexual experience actually becomes the only means of experiencing satisfaction completely and directly. If Rousseau prefers to give up sex for masturbation, Derrida contends that it is because auto-eroticism appears to enable the philosopher to ‘make present’ a string of absent love objects in imaginary or symbolic form: Rousseau’s memories, desires and wishes about the various women in his life can be instantly activated, and satisfied, in auto-erotic fantasy in a way that could never happen in real life. For Derrida, in other words, it is clear that what we generally take to be the sign of the futility of onanism – the fact that it never involves anyone from the world outside the subject – is rather the guarantee of its total fulfilment (p. 154/221)."

 
follow on from previous. it is all cinema, illusions, a lack of real protentions, desires replaced by drives. very much what Stiegler is getting at

"Yet, it remains the case that Rousseau is still sexually frustrated despite this retreat into the world of pure auto-affection. As Derrida goes on to argue, the reason for this is that the immediate ‘present’ delivered to him in the form of auto-erotic fantasy is, of course, nothing but an illusion: Rousseau realises that the signs that substitute for the absence of real women in the philosopher’s sex life remain just signs (p. 154/221). So, upon Derrida’s reading, Rousseau’s auto-erotic experience epitomises what he calls the logic of the supplement: what arrives on the scene to add to, or enrich, a supposedly pure presence also reveals – by virtue of its very necessity – that pure presence has never existed. If masturbatory fantasy is the only way of experiencing the pure pleasure that can never be delivered up by real life, this is another way of saying that there is no pure pleasure as such. In other words, the very thing that appears to give access to pure and immediate presence – the supplement – is also what ensures that presence will never be given as such: ‘something promises itself as it hides itself, gives itself as it moves itself away, and strictly speaking it cannot even be called presence’ (p. 154/222, translation modified"

 
it becomes an escape from the "natural". could llms be viewed in this way when it comes to writing? not just an alleged time saver, but a shield

"Finally, however, Derrida argues that masturbation plays one more unusual role within Rousseau’s life and text: what starts out as a dangerous supplement to the full presence of sex with women paradoxically ends up as a form of protection against a certain danger within this form of presence itself. It is revealing that Rousseau ultimately comes to see auto-eroticism less as a waste of natural energy and more as a means of safeguarding his hypersensitive nature against the dangerously unmitigated pleasure of sex with women: self-abuse turns out to be a form of self-preservation. According to his Confessions, the philosopher abstains from ‘cohabitation with women’ altogether in his middle age on the grounds that the intensity of the experience might damage his fragile health or even kill him.18 For Derrida, Rousseau’s recourse to masturbation as an act of protection against the perils of a real, live sexual encounter with another person once again reveals a certain frailty or insufficiency within pure, unmediated ‘presence’. What is supposedly ‘natural’ or ‘healthy’ is actually a form of sickness that we need to immunise ourselves against. Yet, why is pure presence equated with sickness, or even death, as opposed to life, fullness or plenitude? To embrace presence is to reject life itself. If we could ever really experience pure presence as such – something that was absolutely and unchangingly present in space and time – Derrida argues that this could only be because that thing was entirely lacking in duration, movement, difference, in short, life: this is why Rousseau himself recognises that ‘presence’ is merely another name for death (p. 155/223)."

 
reality is experienced by reducing the supplement

"‘reality’ can only be experienced at one remove through the auto-erotic supplement: ‘hetero-eroticism . . . can be lived . . . only through the ability to reserve within itself its own supplementary protection’ (p. 155/223)."

 
the supplement is originary

"Derrida’s proposition is that the supplement does not add to what was once a pure or complete presence but rather compensates for a ‘presence’ that never actually existed in the first place. To put it in a word, Derrida’s now very familiar argument is that the ‘supplement’ is originary: what A Guide to the Text 109 appears to be a pure or complete moment of presence once again depends for any identity it may possess on its relation to other elements that are not simply present. If such a pure, self-sufficient moment of presence – whether we call it nature, or speech, or sexuality – ever existed, there would no need to produce endless chains of supplements to compensate for its deficiencies."

 
psychoanalysis equally resides within language. what is the subconscious if not the subconscious or a description thereof?

"For Derrida, the problem with psychoanalysis and any other reading that seeks to refer to the world ‘beyond’ the text is that it flies in the face of what we have seen to be the inextricable relationship between the signifier and the signified: we can never gain access to a ‘transcendental signified’ – a mythical beyond – that exists in and of itself independently of all signifiers (p. 159/229). In other words, everything that psychoanalysis and other such methodologies presumes lies outside language – the unconscious, sexuality, history, the real world – cannot be divorced from language itself."

 
no outside text

"‘ there is no outside-text [ il n’y a pas de hors-texte]’ (p. 158/227, translation modified)."

 
no pure presence

"Derrida’s claim that ‘ il n’y a pas de hors-texte’ is neither an attempt to assert that language is the only reality nor to deny the existence of reality per se but rather to stress the impossibility of gaining access to any pure or immediate presence that exists wholly independently of the processes of difference and deferral: Rousseau was never purely or simply ‘there’ in the first place."

 
empiricism is philosophy's account of what non-philosophy should look like

"what philosophy derides as ‘empiricism’ is not actually non-philosophical at all because it only has meaning within the conceptual oppositions determined by metaphysics itself: the rational versus the empirical, the theoretical versus the practical and, more generally, the ‘philosophical’ versus the ‘non-philosophical’. If it seems that empiricism is somehow ‘outside’ metaphysics, in other words, it actually remains a metaphysical concept through and through: empiricism is philosophy’s own idea of what non-philosophy should look like"

 
no pure point of departure. we must start where we are

"For Derrida, his inability to offer an absolute justification for his own reading is neither a rejection of theory nor an embrace of practice but rather the upshot of his attempt to question the metaphysical desire for an absolute ground, origin or foundation on which to base all knowledge. In the absence of any true point of origin, we must begin ‘ wherever we are’ he writes, because the thought of the ‘originary’ trace has already taught us that it is ‘impossible to justify a point of departure absolutely’ (p. 162/233)."

 
the supplement

"For Derrida, then, we might say that the ‘supplement’ is exorbitant in every sense of the term. It is a kind of structural ‘blindspot [ tâche aveugle]’ that resists every attempt to explain it with reference to the categories of metaphysics (p. 163/234). Accordingly, we can see the supplement as neither an addition nor a substitute, neither good nor evil, neither passive nor active, neither a conscious theme in Rousseau’s text nor a manifestation of the unconscious of the author, neither within the enclosure of the text itself, nor ‘outside’ it in some, supposedly extra-textual, ‘real’ world."

 
rousseau - writing buy precision at a price

"writing buys a greater precision but only at the expense of the immediacy and expressiveness of speech."

 
the cold northeners

"Again, Rousseau draws an important distinction, but this time it is between languages of the north and south. On the one side, ‘southern’ languages are said to spring from passion: the warm climate, fertile soil and conditions in Southern Europe and Africa provide man with everything he needs to subsist so he only has to use language in order to express his desires. On the other, however, ‘northern’ languages are deemed to be the result of direct physical need: the cold climate, poor earth and meagre conditions in northern Europe mean that language developed first and foremost as a way of surviving. In Rousseau’s pithy summation, the first words of southern man were ‘love me’ ( aimez-moi) whereas the first words of northern man were ‘help me’ ( aidez-moi) (p. 279)."

 
lifeless harmony

"Rousseau makes an important distinction between two different modes of music: melody and harmony. If melody is the pure expression of our passions, the evolution of harmony introduces a fatal complexity, abstraction and artificiality into music. Just as the written word sacrifices the passion of speech for greater precision of expression, so harmony surrenders the pure and immediate expressiveness of melody in favour of elaborate but lifeless harmonic arrangements (pp. 295–8)."

 
why is the supplement necessary? because the pure origin never existed in the first place

"the originary presence of speech is supplemented by writing, nature by culture, interiority by exteriority, sex by masturbation and so on endlessly. For Rousseau himself, of course, each supplement is nothing more than a pure addition to an origin that is already fully present in itself: what is added is quite literally nothing – a spare part – because the origin itself does not need anything to complete it (p. 167/238). However, the obvious question that follows from here is – if the origin requires no supplement and the supplement adds nothing to the origin – then why does the supplement ever come into existence, why is it necessary?"

 
language and music

"On the contrary, it is the ‘major preoccupation’ of Rousseau’s text (p. 195/279) because the story of language is intimately bound up with the story of music: both begin as ways of giving voice to our passions. To put it in Rousseau’s own words: ‘passion rouses all of the [vocal] organs’ and so song and speech have ‘a common origin’ ( Discourses, p. 282). If language and music have the same origin, however, they also share the same fate: what begins as a simple expression of passion quickly degenerates into a cold, abstract and expres-sionless form."

 
rousseau why oh why harmony

"Upon Rousseau’s reading, then, the first form of music can only have been melody. It is melody, as a monophonic sequence of pure sounds, that is closest to the cry of passion that, for the philosopher, represents the origin of language: ‘melody expresses plaints, cries of suffering or of joy, threats, moans’ ( Discourses, p. 287). Inasmuch as it involves a complex interplay of sounds, harmony is obviously at one remove from this state of nature: ‘what have chords in common with our passions?’ he rhetorically demands (p. 287)."

 
rousseau - death of melody and music

"In Rousseau’s tragic account, contemporary music has lost all connection with the passions that originally gave it life and degenerated into pure harmony (p. 298)."

 
what is the lack that LLMs reveal?

"In Derrida’s account, of course, the answer is by now obvious: the supplement does not add to nature but reveal a lack – an originary difference – within the natural itself ( Grammatology, p. 214/308)."

 
rousseau - the supplement necessitates itself

"To put it in a nutshell, what Rousseau calls ‘nature’ is not complete in itself but is rather an originary deficiency – a non-identity, mediation or différance – that demands supplementation by imitation: [I]n every imitation, some sort of discourse must always complement the voice of nature. A musician who tries to render noise with noise errs; he knows neither the weaknesses nor the strengths of his art; he judges of it without taste or insight; teach him that he must render noise with song, that if he wished to make frogs croak he would have to make them sing; for it is not enough for him merely to imitate, he must do so in a way that both moves and pleases, otherwise his dreary imitation is as nought, and by failing to arouse anyone’s interest, it fails to make any impression. ( Discourse, p. 288) For Derrida, then, it is clear that everything Rousseau seeks to oppose to the pure and unmediated voice of nature – harmony, imitation, culture, society – exists in order to supply, correct, or compensate for, what increasingly looks like an inherent deficiency, which in the above passage is figured as a rawness, ugliness or noise, within that voice that calls for supplementation: what seems to belong outside nature is, as we have seen throughout this book, always already working within it in order to make it what it should be in the first place. What implications, then, does this ‘becoming-supplemental’ of nature itself hold for Rousseau’s theory of the origin of language?"

 
what rousseau means to say, what he cannot help to say

"Once again, what Derrida is trying to do here is to identify a point of A Guide to the Text 127 ‘exorbitancy’ in Rousseau’s text where the philosopher’s declared aims or intentions are overtaken or surprised by larger forces. For Derrida, it is this gap between what Rousseau declares and what he actually describes – what he means to say and what he cannot help but say – that is the site of his own reading."

 
no such thing as absolutely north and south

"Yet, Rousseau’s account of the origin of language tries to freeze this essential relativity and variability into a set of static, absolute differences. Every language is assigned an absolutely fixed position on the globe – either the North Pole or the South Pole – as if no position between these two extremities could possibly exist! For Derrida, in other words, Rousseau’s attempt to claim that the true origin of language lies in a so-called absolute South is at odds with what it describes: we cannot say that any language is absolutely ‘northern’ or ‘southern’ because languages have, at best, a relative position in the world. If Rousseau seeks to distinguish categorically between northern and southern languages, Derrida’s argument is that this distinction is rather a question of degree: we can speak of languages that are more ‘northern’ and less ‘southern’ – more passionate and less necessary – but we cannot make any absolute distinction between the two. In this sense, what Rousseau’s attempt to distinguish between north and south actually describes is not a polar opposition between two diametrically opposed kinds of language but a more subtle, less clear-cut distribution of forces within every single language: every language contains elements of both north and south, passion and need ( Grammatology, p. 217/310)."

 
language of need and passion

"Derrida goes to great lengths to show how the language of need is ‘forever related’ to the language of passion ‘persevering in it, submitting to it or controlling it’ (p. 223/319).22 In this sense, we must see the language of need as a supplement to the language of passion in the full sense of that term: what Rousseau calls the ‘North’ is not somewhere that exists at the furthest remove from the one true origin of language, in other words, but is rather the outworking of ‘another origin’ that compensates for what the first origin lacks (p. 224/319)."

 
language is always already articulate

"Derrida once again seeks to question this mythological account of a fall from a pure, self-present and undifferentiated state of nature into the atomised, divided and unequal world of modern, civic society. If Rousseau typically presents articulation as a degeneration or catastrophe that affects the original condition of language from without, as if the peoples of the northern hemisphere were not human beings at all but aliens from another planet, what his own account again reveals is that the apparent ‘supplement’ is essential to what it supplements. Just as melody is harmony, south is north, and passion is need, so we will discover that language is always already articulate from the very beginning (p. 229/325)."

 
all language is writing

"Derrida’s account, as we will see later on, this insight has important knock-on effects for Rousseau’s theory of writing as well because, for the latter, the defining quality of the written word is nothing other than this articulacy: the claim that all ‘language is articulate’ is thus another way of saying that ‘all language is writing’ (p. 229/326)."

 
language is born from writing - its own degeneration

"For Rousseau, the origin of human language does not lie in any particular organ, such as the larynx or vocal chords, so much as in the acquisition of the necessary signs, symbols or conventions that enable us to communicate ideas in the form of sounds: ‘[c]onventional language belongs to man alone’ ( Discourses, p. 252). If human beings must first acquire a repertoire of complex cultural conventions in order to express even our most basis passions – love, anger, pity and so on – then it becomes difficult to see how Rousseau can speak of a ‘natural’ language at all: the use of conventional language is, on the contrary, precisely what distinguishes human life from the natural world. The argument that the pure, inarticulate cry of nature is not yet language in any meaningful sense of the term leads us to the conclusion that what characterises language is nothing other than articulation. This capacity to articulate sound, to cut up the cry of nature up into what Saussure would call a series of phonic signifiers, is the basis of all human language whether northern or southern, passionate or necessary. So, in a paradoxical sense, then, what Rousseau presents as the ruination of language – the intervention of difference, spacing, supplementarity in the form of articulation – is actually its condition of possibility: ‘ language is born out of the process of its own degeneration’ Derrida writes ( Grammatology, p. 242/344)."

 
harmony supplants melody. rousseau

"As we know, Rousseau’s text understands the history of language as the progression, or rather regression, from one supplement for the origin to another: harmony supplements melody, articulation replaces accent, etc. To Derrida’s eyes, however, it is writing that is the supplement par excellence in the Essay: what happens when the written word comes on the scene is the final triumph of difference over presence, mediation over immediacy, coldness or death over the life and warmth of speech."

 
all language is written

"If all language is articulate from the very outset, however, and all articulation just as inevitably leads to writing, then it logically follows that all language might just as easily be called written: what the historical invention of the written word comes to replace is, paradoxically enough, not speech or expressiveness but a version of itself A Guide to the Text 135 (p. 315/443)."

 
meta physical language unavoidable

"We have no choice but to employ metaphysical language even if what we are attempting to articulate or designate – arche-writing, originary trace or supplementation – is impossible or nonsensical within those terms (p. 314/443)."

 
derrida isnt rejecting metaphysics, but rather accepting it and making it visible. argues for deconstruction as a possibility of dealing with it

"Derrida’s own words, deconstruction escapes the metaphysics of presence by nothing more than a ‘hairsbreadth’ ( une pointe) (p. 315/443), but arguably the major achievement of the Grammatology is to define, map and exist within this vital critical space."

 
grammatology is science of everything

"what Derrida calls ‘writing’ is not simply the condition of language because it also describes the field of consciousness, perception and our experience of ‘reality’ in general. In this sense, what is called ‘grammatology’ is not merely the science of writing but the science of everything: we cannot experience anything in an unmediated way."

 
ethics, levinas, originary trace

"Levinas’s way of thinking, we only begin to acquire our own sense of subjectivity through a feeling of being indebted or responsible to an ‘other [ autrui]’ that exceeds any idea we might have of it.27 For Derrida, it is clear that the logic of the originary trace has profound ethical implications in the manner proposed by Levinas: the structure of ‘the trace’, Derrida says in the Grammatology, is also the structure of the relation to ‘the other’ (p. 47/69). To understand the structure of the originary trace, in other words, is to be aware of the constancy of something or someone absolutely ‘other’ within the order of the ‘same’. Every apparently single, autonomous or self-identical element only acquires its identity by reference to some other element that differs from it in space and time. If we translate this logic into more explicitly ethical terms, we gain a radical new vision of our relation to the world around us, to other people and things, to other ways of living, being or thinking. In Derrida’s account, we do not pre-exist the other as if we all lived in our own private universes and only later decided to enter the outside world: our own identity, subjectivity or sense of self is originally and essentially constituted by a relation to a potentially infinite number of others."

 
but can also be seen less grandly as a means to analyse things

"For Bernard Stiegler, a contemporary philosopher of technology, Derrida’s critique of a real, natural or unmediated ‘presence’ in the name of an originary supplementarity makes possible a new and more radical understanding of the role played by technology in the formation of human life: what is traditionally seen as a mere tool or supplement to nature is in fact the condition of life, thought and our experience of time." Chapter 3: Study Aids

 
deconstruction as a positive process

"First of all, deconstruction is not a philosophical destruction or demolition but an affirmative process that seeks to reconstruct a given system or structure otherwise: it is the ‘undoing, decomposing and de-sedimenting of structures’ in order to ‘understand how an “ensemble” was constituted and to reconstruct it to this end’ (‘Letter to a Japanese Friend’, p. 272)."

 
logocentrism historically favours speech. derrida shows its faults

"To Derrida’s eyes, however, what really defines logocentrism is that it always privileges speech ( phone) over writing ( gramme) as the means by which the presence of the logos is expressed: ‘the history of truth has always been . . . the debasement of writing and its repression outside “full” speech’ (p. 3/12). If logocentrism is so deeply ingrained within western thought and culture that we might think it merely describes ‘the way things are’, Derrida shows that it is in fact the product of a set of highly problematic assumptions about presence, speech and particularly writing."

 
metaphysics of presence - not binary oppositions, thoroughly determined by the originary trace, differances

"According to Derrida, the western philosophical tradition from Plato to the present day dogmatically posits a pure, full and unmediated presence as the supreme value. To Derrida’s way of thinking, this ‘presence’ Study Aids 149 can take many forms: the presence of the subject to itself in thought, sight or touch, the presence of something in space and/or time, even a presence which has now been lost or which may be gained in the future. For Derrida, the metaphysics of presence expresses itself through the institution of a series of binary oppositions and hierarchies whereby a superior term will be identified with pure presence and an inferior term with the mediation or loss of that presence: speech versus writing, nature versus culture, the masculine versus the feminine and so on. In the Grammatology, Derrida seeks to deconstruct these binary oppositions by articulating a logic of mediation, difference and deferral that makes them possible in the first place."

 
the supplement - the logic of differance. what should be fully present reveals its lacks

"The Supplement ( le supplément) This is a key term that appears in Derrida’s reading of Jean-Jacques Rousseau. It is one of the various ways throughout the Grammatology in which Derrida articulates the logic of difference, deferral and mediation that undercuts the metaphysics of presence. According to Derrida, the figure of the supplement performs two irreconcilable roles within Rousseau’s text. On the one hand, Rousseau continually presents it as an addition to something that is already full, present and sufficient in itself. On the other, Rousseau’s text consistently reveals that it is a substitute, or compensation for, something that is essentially lacking, insufficient in itself (p. 145/208). For Derrida, then, the logic of the supplement becomes a means of deconstructing Rousseau’s logocentric commitment to presence: what should be fully ‘present’ in itself is revealed to contain an essential lack or absence that always calls for supplementation in the first place. In Derrida’s account, we can thus speak of an ‘originary’ supplement in the same way that we would speak of an originary trace, writing or difference."

 
signs obtain meaning only through differance _Generated at: 2026-11-03-09-01-15_

"Derrida argues that every sign can only obtain meaning in itself by differing in space and time from other signs in the linguistic system. To Derrida’s eyes, this means that every sign must originally retain the traces of the other signs against which it is to be defined if it is to achieve any meaning at all. For Derrida, however, this ‘originary’ trace becomes the means for deconstructing not simply Saussure’s theory of the sign but the entire edifice of the metaphysics of presence: it re-describes ‘the entire field of being [ étant], which metaphysics has defined as the being-present [ étant-présent]’ (p. 47/69, translation modified). In Derrida’s account, every supposedly ‘present’ element originally and essentially contains the traces of other elements that are supposedly ‘absent’: nothing, there-fore, is ever wholly present or absent"

Kuchtová, A. (2024). The incalculability of the generated text. Philosophy & Technology, 37(1), 25.   
Added by: alexb44   Last edited by: alexb44 12/10/2026, 02:08
Moon, K., Kushlev, K., Bank, A., Luttges, B., Viskontas, I., & Kaufman, J., et al. (2026). The link between diverse words and original ideas is weakening in the AI-era college admissions.   
Added by: alexb44   Last edited by: Mark Grimshaw-Aagaard 25/09/2026, 08:35
Ong, W. J., & Hartley, J. (2013). Orality and literacy. Routledge.    
Added by: alexb44   Last edited by: alexb44 29/10/2026, 03:17
recasting the human mind

"Recasting the human mind as a product of media took medieval rhetoric out of the seminary and put it in the world of what are now known as “ Mad Men ” (advertisers from Madison Avenue).22 It is in this context that the idea of a medium being able to shape and transform consciousness took popular hold, just as Vietnam, sex and drugs and rock’n’roll were setting campuses alight with the idea that consciousness ought to be changed in various ways, as soon as possible and with whatever semiotic or chemical assistance was to hand."

 
mentality between oral and literary

"The shift from orality to literacy and on to electronic processing engages social, economic, political, religious and other structures. These, however, are only indirect concerns of the present book, which treats rather the differences in ‘mentality’ between oral and writing cultures."

 
saussure, complement orality

"Writing, he noted, has simultaneously ‘usefulness, shortcomings and dangers’ (1959, pp. 23–4). Still he thought of writing as a kind of complement to oral speech, not as a transformer of verbalization (Saussure 1959, pp. 23–4)."

 
even sign language comes after orality

"Despite the richness of gesture, elaborated sign languages are substitutes for speech and dependent on oral speech systems, even when used by the congenitally deaf (Kroeber 1972; Mallery 1972; Stokoe 1972)."

 
never completely. oh, the foolishness of natural language programming

"Writing can never dispense with orality. Adapting a term used for slightly different purposes by Jurij Lotman (1977, pp. 21, 48–61; see also Champagne 1977–8), we can style writing a ‘secondary modeling system’, dependent on a prior primary system, spoken language. Oral expression can exist and mostly has existed without any writing at all, writing never without orality."

 
q

"The fulsome praise in the old, residually oral, rhetoric tradition strikes persons from a high-literacy culture as insincere, flatulent, and comically pretentious. But praise goes with the highly polarized, agonistic, oral world of good and evil, virtue and vice, villains and heroes."

 
writing initially enhanced orality through rhetoric. again a testament to the pharmakon?

"Thus writing from the beginning did not reduce orality but enhanced it, making it possible to organize the ‘principles’ or constituents of oratory into a scientific ‘art’, a sequentially ordered body of explanation that showed how and why oratory achieved and could be made to achieve its various specific effects."

 
new orality

"It is ‘primary’ by contrast with the ‘secondary orality’ of present-day high technology culture, in which a new orality is sustained by telephone, radio, television, and other electronic devices that depend for their existence and functioning on writing and print."

 
how LLMs see all of the world, only with no points of reference

"Thinking of oral tradition or a heritage of oral performance, genres and styles as ‘oral literature’ is rather like thinking of horses as automobiles without wheels. You can, of course, undertake to do this. Imagine writing a treatise on horses (for people who have never seen a horse) which starts with the concept not of horse but of ‘automobile’, built on the readers’ direct experience of automobiles. It proceeds to discourse on horses by always referring to them as ‘wheelless automobiles’, explaining to highly auto mobilized readers who have never seen a horse all the points of difference in an effort to excise all idea of ‘automobile’ out of the concept ‘wheelless automobile’ so as to invest the term with a purely equine meaning. Instead of wheels, the wheelless automobiles have enlarged toenails called hooves; instead of headlights or perhaps rear-vision mirrors, eyes; instead of a coat of lacquer, something called hair; instead of gasoline for fuel, hay, and so on. In the end, horses are only what they are not. No matter how accurate and thorough such apophatic description, automobile-driving readers who have never seen a horse and who hear only of ‘wheelless automobiles’ would be sure to come away with a strange concept of a horse. The same is true of those who deal in terms of ‘oral literature’, that is, ‘oral writing’. You cannot without serious and disabling distortion describe a primary phenomenon by starting with a subsequent secondary phenomenon and paring away the differences. Indeed, starting backwards in this way – putting the car before the horse – you can never become aware of the real differences at all."

 
literacy as pharmakon

"Fortunately, literacy, though it consumes its own oral antecedents and, unless it is carefully monitored, even destroys their memory, is also infinitely adaptable. It can restore their memory, too. Literacy can be used to reconstruct for ourselves the pristine human consciousness which was not literate at all – at least to reconstruct this consciousness pretty well, though not perfectly (we can never forget enough of our familiar present to reconstitute in our minds any past in its full integrity). Such reconstruction can bring a better understanding of what literacy itself has meant in shaping man’s consciousness toward and in high technology cultures. Such understanding of both orality and literacy is what this book, which is of necessity a literate work and not an oral performance, attempts in some degree to achieve."

 
cliches became necessary to keep them remembered

"Certain of these wider implications remained to be worked out later in great detail by Eric A. Havelock (1963). Homeric Greeks valued clichés because not only the poets but the entire oral noetic world or thought world relied upon the formulaic constitution of thought. In an oral culture, knowledge, once acquired, had to be constantly repeated or it would be lost: fixed, formulaic thought patterns were essential for wisdom and effective administration."

 
Plato defended essentially the very thing he was scared of in writing

"All these are disturbing conclusions for a western culture that has identified closely with Homer as part of an idealized Greek antiquity. They show Homeric Greece cultivating as a poetic and noetic virtue what we have regarded as a vice, and they show that the relationship between Homeric Greece and everything that philosophy after Plato stood for was, however superficially cordial and continuous, in fact deeply antagonistic, if often at the unconscious rather than the conscious level. The conflict wracked Plato’s own unconscious. For Plato expresses serious reservations in the Phaedrus and his Seventh Letter about writing, as a mechanical, inhuman way of processing knowledge, unresponsive to questions and destructive of memory, although, as we now know, the philosophical thinking Plato fought for depended entirely on writing. No wonder the implications here resisted surfacing for so long. The importance of ancient Greek civilization to all the world was beginning to show in an entirely new light: it marked the point in human history when deeply interiorized alphabetic literacy first clashed head-on with orality. And, despite Plato’s uneasiness, at the time neither Plato nor anyone else was or could be explicitly aware that this was what was going on."

 
early writing is essentially written orality

"Early written poetry everywhere, it seems, is at first necessarily a mimicking in script of oral performance. The mind has initially no properly chirographic resources. You scratch out on a surface words you imagine yourself saying aloud in some realizable oral setting. Only very gradually does writing become composition in writing, a kind of discourse – poetic or otherwise – that is put together without a feeling that the one writing is actually speaking aloud (as early writers may well have done in composing)."

 
oral habits of thought and expression lingered

"Oral habits of thought and expression, including massive use of formulaic elements, sustained in use largely by the teaching of the old classical rhetoric, still marked prose style of almost every sort in Tudor England some two thousand years after Plato’s campaign against oral poets (Ong 1971, pp. 23–47)."

 
breakdown of bicamerality

"For example, the early and late stages of consciousness which Julian Jaynes (1977) describes and relates to neurophysiological changes in the bicameral mind would also appear to lend themselves largely to much simpler and more verifiable description in terms of a shift from orality to literacy. Jaynes discerns a primitive stage of consciousness in which the brain was strongly ‘bicameral’, with the right hemisphere producing uncontrollable ‘voices’ attributed to the gods which the left hemisphere processed into speech. The ‘voices’ began to lose their effectiveness between 2000 and 1000 BC. This period, it will be noted, is neatly bisected by the invention of the alphabet around 1500 BC, and Jaynes indeed believes that writing helped bring about the breakdown of the original bicamerality."

 
llms gateway to bicameral minds?

"Whatever one makes of Jaynes’s theories, one cannot but be struck by the resemblance between the characteristics of the early or ‘bicameral’ psyche as Jaynes describes it – lack of introspectivity, of analytic prowess, of concern with the will as such, of a sense of difference between past and future – and the characteristics of the psyche in oral cultures not only in the past but even today. The effects of oral states of consciousness are bizarre to the literate mind, and they can invite elaborate explanations which may turn out to be needless. Bicamerality may mean simply orality. The question of orality and bicamerality perhaps needs further investigation."

 
unless what we want to examine is the motion

"Indeed, it favors immobility, for to examine something closely by vision, we prefer to have it quiet."

 
even this woule be out of reach for an llm

"Deeply typographic folk forget to think of words as primarily oral, as events, and hence as necessarily powered: for them, words tend rather to be assimilated to things, ‘out there’ on a flat surface. Such ‘things’ are not so readily associated with magic, for they are not actions, but are in a radical sense dead, though subject to dynamic resurrection (Ong 1977, pp. 230–71)."

 
but even this in its own right does not produce knowledge. encyclopedic knowledge is different from tacit knowledge

"An oral culture has no texts. How does it get together organized material for recall? This is the same as asking, ‘What does it or can it know in an organized fashion?’ Suppose a person in an oral culture would undertake to think through a particular complex problem and would finally manage to articulate a solution which itself is relatively complex, consisting, let us say, of a few hundred words. How does he or she retain for later recall the verbalization so painstakingly elaborated? In the total absence of any writing, there is nothing outside the thinker, no text, to enable him or her to produce the same line of thought again or even to verify whether he or she has done so or not. Aides-mémoire such as notched sticks or a series of carefully arranged objects will not of themselves retrieve a complicated series of assertions. How, in fact, could a lengthy, analytic solution ever be assembled in the first place? An interlocutor is virtually essential: it is hard to talk to yourself for hours on end. Sustained thought in an oral culture is tied to communication."

 
formulas were necessary for prolonged thought as mesns of remembering mnemonically

"Formulas help implement rhythmic discourse and also act as mnemonic aids in their own right, as set expressions circulating through the mouths and ears of all. ‘Red in the morning, the sailor’s warning; red in the night, the sailor’s delight.’ ‘Divide and conquer.’ ‘To err is human, to forgive is divine.’ ‘Sorrow is better than laughter, because when the face is sad the heart grows wiser’ (Ecclesiastes 7:3). ‘The clinging vine.’ ‘The sturdy oak.’ ‘Chase off nature and she returns at a gallop.’ Fixed, often rhythmically balanced, expressions of this sort and of other sorts can be found occasionally in print, indeed can be ‘looked up’ in books of sayings, but in oral cultures they are not occasional. They are incessant. They form the substance of thought itself. Thought in any extended form is impossible without them, for it consists in them."

 
the law is in the formulaic nature

"The law itself in oral cultures is enshrined in formulaic sayings, proverbs, which are not mere jurisprudential decorations, but themselves constitute the law. A judge in an oral culture is often called on to articulate sets of relevant proverbs out of which he can produce equitable decisions in the cases under formal litigation before him (Ong 1978, p. 5)"

 
allowing llm text to become commonplace is allowing non-sensical text to govern whatcis perceived as normal

"It would be a mistake to think that the Douay is simply ‘closer’ to the original today than the New American is. It is closer in that it renders we or wa always by the same word, but it strikes the present-day sensibility as remote, archaic, and even quaint. Peoples in oral cultures or cultures with high oral residue, including the culture that produced the Bible, do not savor this sort of expression as so archaic or quaint. It feels natural and normal to them somewhat as the New American version feels natural and normal to us."

 
the savage mind - what about the docile mind?

"As Lévi- Strauss has well put it in a summary statement ‘the savage [i.e. oral] mind totalizes’ (1966, p. 245)."

 
equally, anybody who accepts an llm as a source of understanding diminishes their own need to understand. it is always right there at a moments notice

"Redundant or ‘copious’ Thought requires some sort of continuity. Writing establishes in the text a ‘line’ of continuity outside the mind. If distraction confuses or obliterates from the mind the context out of which emerges the material I am now reading, the context can be retrieved by glancing back over the text selectively. Backlooping can be entirely occasional, purely ad hoc. The mind concentrates its own energies on moving ahead because what it backloops into lies quiescent outside itself, always available piecemeal on the inscribed page. In"

 
the technology of writing

"Clanchy (1979, pp. 88–115) discusses the matter circumstantially, in its western medieval context, in his chapter entitled ‘The technology of writing’."

 
rhetoric changed from art of public speaking to art of writing

"The public speaker’s need to keep going while he is running through his mind what to say next also encourages redundancy. In oral delivery, though a pause may be effective, hesitation is always disabling. Hence it is better to repeat something, artfully if possible, rather than simply to stop speaking while fishing for the next idea. Oral cultures encourage fluency, fulsomeness, volubility. Rhetoricians were to call this copia. They continued to encourage it, by a kind of oversight, when they had modulated rhetoric from an art of public speaking to an art of writing."

 
oral societies conservative, need to repeat out loud, values those wise people who specialise in conserving it

"Since in a primary oral culture conceptualized knowledge that is not repeated aloud soon vanishes, oral societies must invest great energy in saying over and over again what has been learned arduously over the ages. This need establishes a highly traditionalist or conservative set of mind that with good reason inhibits intellectual experimentation. Knowledge is hard to come by and precious, and society regards highly those wise old men and women who specialize in conserving it, who know and can tell the stories of the days of old. By storing knowledge outside the mind, writing and, even more, print downgrade the figures of the wise old man and the wise old woman, repeaters of the past, in favor of younger discoverers of something new."

 
orality forces closeness to life-world. writing obscures that connection. what do llms do?

"the absence of elaborate analytic categories that depend on writing to structure knowledge at a distance from lived experience, oral cultures must conceptualize and verbalize all their knowledge with more or less close reference to the human lifeworld, assimilating the alien, objective world to the more immediate, familiar interaction of human beings. A chirographic (writing) culture and even more a typographic (print) culture can distance and in a way denature even the human, itemizing such things as the names of leaders and political divisions in an abstract, neutral list entirely devoid of a human action context."

 
orality fosters intellectual combat

"Many, if not all, oral or residually oral cultures strike literates as extraordinarily agonistic in their verbal performance and indeed in their lifestyle. Writing fosters abstractions that disengage knowledge from the arena where human beings struggle with one another. It separates the knower from the known. By keeping knowledge embedded in the human lifeworld, orality situates knowledge within a context of struggle. Proverbs and riddles are not used simply to store knowledge but to engage others in verbal and intellectual combat: utterance of one proverb or riddle challenges hearers to top it with a more apposite or a contradictory one (Abrahams 1968; 1972). Bragging"

 
orality knows by getting with it, writing takes distance - "objectivity"

"For an oral culture learning or knowing means achieving close, empathetic, communal identification with the known (Havelock 1963, pp. 145–6), ‘getting with it’. Writing separates the knower from the known and thus sets up conditions for ‘objectivity’, in the sense of personal disengagement or distancing."

 
what do llm societies do?

"By contrast with literate societies, oral societies can be characterized as homeostatic (Goody and Watt 1968, pp. 31–4). That is to say, oral societies live very much in a present which keeps itself in equilibrium or homeostasis by sloughing off memories which no longer have present relevance."

 
dictionaries advertise semantic discrepancies. what do llms advertise? nick wanted to tell us abiut the worlds most impactful person throughout history, which he had asked an llm about. when he wanted to show it he could not get the ssme answer and find the man... if people truly believe the everything machine can know such things, what does that do to knowledge and information? what is the definition of sound? encyclopedic knowledge, which is one of the objective forms of preserving information or knowledge over time, helps us keep these definitions. yet they can maintain wrongful information. arguably these definitions are pretty far from what we know about sound today, yet they're useful because theyre static until they are very deliberately changed. llms make every bit of knowledge increasingly ambiguous and unsteady,. its hard to play jenga during an earthquake

"The forces governing homeostasis can be sensed by reflection on the condition of words in a primary oral setting. Print cultures have invented dictionaries in which the various meanings of a word as it occurs in datable texts can be recorded in formal definitions. Words thus are known to have layers of meaning, many of them quite irrelevant to ordinary present meanings. Dictionaries advertise semantic discrepancies."

 
oral society and semantic ratification

"Oral cultures of course have no dictionaries and few semantic discrepancies. The meaning of each word is controlled by what Goody and Watt (1968, p. 29) call ‘direct semantic ratification’, that is, by the real-life situations in which the word is used here and now. The oral mind is uninterested in definitions (Laura 1976, pp. 48–99). Words acquire their meanings only from their always insistent actual habitat, which is not, as in a dictionary, simply other words, but includes also gestures, vocal inflections, facial expression, and the entire human, existential setting in which the real, spoken word always occurs. Word meanings come continuously out of the present, though past meanings of course have shaped the present meaning in many and varied ways, no longer recognized."

 
oral traditions reflect current values

"Goody and Watt (1968, p. 33) report an even more strikingly detailed case of ‘structural amnesia’ among the Gonja in Ghana. Written records made by the British at the turn of the twentieth century show that Gonja oral tradition then presented Ndewura Jakpa, the founder of the state of Gonja, as having had seven sons, each of whom was ruler of one of the seven territorial divisions of the state. By the time sixty years later when the myths of state were again recorded, two of the seven divisions had disappeared, one by assimilation to another division and the other by reason of a boundary shift. In these later myths, Ndewura Jakpa had five sons, and no mention was made of the two extinct divisions. The Gonja were still in contact with their past, tenacious about this contact in their myths, but the part of the past with no immediately discernible relevance to the present had simply fallen away. The present imposed its own economy on past remembrances. Packard (1980, p. 157) has noted that Claude Lévi-Strauss, T. O. Beidelman, Edmund Leach and others have suggested that oral traditions reflect a society’s present cultural values rather than idle curiosity about the past. He finds this is true of the Bashu, as Harms (1980, p. 178) finds it also true of the Bobangi."

 
conceptual thinking is abstract

"All conceptual thinking is to a degree abstract. So ‘concrete’ a term as ‘tree’ does not refer simply to a singular ‘concrete’ tree but is an abstraction, drawn out of, away from, individual, sensible actuality; it refers to a concept which is neither this tree nor that tree but can apply to any tree. Each individual object that we style a tree is truly ‘concrete’, simply itself, not ‘abstract’ at all, but the term we apply to the individual object is in itself abstract. Nevertheless, if all conceptual thinking is thus to some degree abstract, some uses of concepts are more abstract than other uses."

 
how do LLMs affect our noetic processes?

"He identifies the persons he interviews on a scale ranging from illiteracy to various levels of moderate literacy and his data fall clearly into the classes of orally based versus chirographically based noetic processes."

 
literacy changes thought process

"The contrasts that show between illiterates (by far the larger number of his subjects) and literates as such are marked and certainly significant (often Luria notes this fact explicitly) and they show what work reported on and cited by Carothers (1959) also shows: it takes only a moderate degree of literacy to make a tremendous difference in thought processes."

 
what Feynman takes some issue with

"(1) Illiterate (oral) subjects identified geometrical figures by assigning them the names of objects, never abstractly as circles, squares, etc. A circle would be called a plate, sieve, bucket, watch, or moon; a square would be called a mirror, door, house, apricot drying-board. Luria’s subjects identified the designs as representations of real things they knew. They never dealt with abstract circles or squares but rather with concrete objects. Teachers’ school students on the other hand, moderately literate, identified geometrical figures by categorical geometric names: circles, squares, triangles, and so on (1976, pp. 32–9). They had been trained to give school-room answers, not real-life responses."

 
situational thinking

"A 25-year-old illiterate peasant: ‘They’re all alike. The saw will saw the log and the hatchet will chop it into small pieces. If one of these has to go, I’d throw out the hatchet. It doesn’t do as good a job as a saw’ (1976, p. 56). Told that the hammer, saw, and hatchet are all tools, he discounts the categorical class and persists in situational thinking: ‘Yes, but even if we have tools, we still need wood – otherwise we can’t build anything’ (ibid.)."

 
by all accounts true to them

"They were convinced that thinking other than operational thinking, that is, categorical thinking, was not important, uninteresting, trivializing (1976, pp. 54–5)."

 
does modern academic thinking simply background nuance? what becomes important is simply what gets priority. also phones steal focus

"One recalls Malinowski’s account (1923, p. 502) of how ‘primitives’ (oral peoples) have names for the fauna and flora that are useful in their lives but treat other things in the forest as unimportant generalized background: ‘That is just “bush”.’ ‘Merely a flying animal.’"

 
primary orality wins, you can only walk away from it

"(4) In Luria’s field work, requests for definitions of even the most concrete objects met with resistance. ‘Try to explain to me what a tree is.’ ‘Why should I? Everyone knows what a tree is, they don’t need me telling them’, replied one illiterate peasant, aged 22 (1976, p. 86). Why define, when a real-life setting is infinitely more satisfactory than a definition? Basically, the peasant was right. There is no way to refute the world of primary orality. All you can do is walk away from it into literacy."

 
the exact reason LLMs csnnot go beyond human knowledge, snd why we see logic in them - always relate to us

"‘How would you define a tree in two words?’ ‘In two words? Apple tree, elm, poplar.’ ‘Say you go to a place where there are no cars. What will you tell people [a car is]?’ ‘If I go, I’ll tell them that buses have four legs, chairs in front for people to sit on, a roof for shade and an engine. But when you get right down to it, I’d say: “If you get in a car and go for a drive, you’ll find out.”’ The respondent enumerates some features but turns back ultimately to personal, situational experience (1976, p. 87)."

 
illiterates cant reflect as well

"(5) Luria’s illiterates had difficulty in articulate self-analysis. Selfanalysis requires a certain demolition of situational thinking. It calls for isolation of the self, around which the entire lived world swirls for each individual person, removal of the center of every situation from that situation enough to allow the center, the self, to be examined and described. Luria put his questions only after protracted conversation about people’s characteristics and their individual differences (1976, p. 148). A 38-year-old man, illiterate, from a mountain pasture camp was asked (1976, p. 150), ‘What sort of person are you, what’s your character like, what are your good qualities and shortcomings? How would you describe yourself?’ ‘I came here from Uch-Kurgan, I was very poor, and now I’m married and have children.’ ‘Are you satisfied with yourself or would you like to be different?’ ‘It would be good if I had a little more land and could sow some wheat.’ Externals command attention. ‘And what are your shortcomings?’ ‘This year I sowed one pood of wheat, and we’re gradually fixing the shortcomings.’ More external situations. ‘Well, people are different – calm, hot-tempered, or sometimes their memory is poor. What do you think of yourself?’ ‘We behave well – if we were bad people, no one would respect us’ (1976, p. 15). Self-evaluation modulated into group evaluation (‘we’) and then handled in terms of expected reactions from others. Another man, a peasant aged 36, asked what sort of person he was, responded with touching and humane directness: ‘What can I say about my own heart? How can I talk about my character? Ask others; they can tell you about me. I myself can’t say anything.’ Judgement bears in on the individual from outside, not from within."

 
ingelligence of oral people

"Gladwin (1970, p. 219) notes that the Pulawat Islanders in the South Pacific respect their navigators, who have to be highly intelligent for their complex and demanding skill, not because they consider them ‘intelligent’ but quite simply because they are good navigators. Asked what he thought of a new village school principal, a Central African responded to Carrington (1974, p. 61), ‘Let’s watch a little how he dances’. Oral folk assess intelligence not as extrapolated from contrived textbook quizzes but as situated in operational contexts."

 
intelligence tests

"Proponents of intelligence tests need to recognize that our ordinary intelligence test questions are tailored to a special kind of consciousness, one deeply conditioned by literacy and print, ‘modern consciousness’ (Berger 1978). A highly intelligent person from an oral or residually oral culture might be expected normally to react to Luria’s type of question, as many of his respondents clearly did, not by answering the seemingly mindless question itself but by trying to assess the total puzzling context (the oral mind totalizes): What is he asking me this stupid question for? What is he trying to do? (See also Ong 1978, p. 4). ‘What is a tree?’ Does he really expect me to respond to that when he and everyone else has seen thousands of trees? Riddles I can work with. But this is no riddle. Is it a game? Of course it is a game, but the oral person is unfamiliar with the rules. The people who ask such questions have been living in a barrage of such questions from infancy and are not aware that they are using special rules."

 
why is pen and paper so effective? slow engagement with our thoughts that create a deeper understanding? through this process we massage our consciousness in a different way. writing is not one thing, and is used in vastly different ways it is in actuql writing we structure arguments and see logic. that is whst writing does and how it re-wires our consciousness

"In a society with some literacy, such as that of Luria’s subjects, illiterates can and often do of course have experience of literately organized thinking on the part of others. They will, for example, have heard someone read written compositions or have heard conversations such as only literates can engage in. One value of Luria’s work is that it shows that such passing acquaintanceship with literate organization of knowledge has, at least so far as his cases show, no discernible effect on illiterates. Writing has to be personally interiorized to affect thinking processes."

 
see previous note

"Persons who have interiorized writing not only write but also speak literately, which is to say that they organize, to varying degrees, even their oral expression in thought patterns and verbal patterns that they would not know of unless they could write. Because it does not follow these patterns, literates have considered oral organization of thought naive."

 
oral intelligence is different

"Nor must we imagine that orally based thought is ‘prelogical’ or ‘illogical’ in any simplistic sense – such as, for example, in the sense that oral folk do not understand causal relationships. They know very well that if you push hard on a mobile object, the push causes it to move. What is true is that they cannot organize elaborate concatenations of causes in the analytic kind of linear sequences which can only be set up with the help of texts. The lengthy sequences they produce, such as genealogies, are not analytic but aggregative. But oral cultures can produce amazingly complex and intelligent and beautiful organizations of thought and experience. To understand how they do so, it will be necessary to discuss some of the operations of oral memory."

 
literacy kills the oral poet

"Most of these living South Slavic narrative poets – and indeed all of the better ones – are illiterate. Learning to read and write disables the oral poet, Lord found: it introduces into his mind the concept of a text as controlling the narrative and thereby interferes with the oral composing processes, which have nothing to do with texts but are ‘the remembrance of songs sung’ (Peabody 1975, p. 216)."

 
like a real-life sampler with intuition

"Oral poets’ memory of songs sung is agile: it was ‘not unusual’ to find a Yugoslav bard singing ‘from ten to twenty ten-syllable lines a minute’ (Lord 1960, p. 17). Comparison of the recorded songs, however, reveals that, though metrically regular, they were never sung the same way twice. Basically the same formulas and themes recurred, but they were stitched together or ‘rhapsodized’ differently in each rendition even by the same poet, depending on audience reaction, the mood of the poet or of the occasion, and other social and psychological factors."

 
wasnt exactly the same, simply alike

"One of the most telling discoveries in Lord’s work has been that, although singers are aware that two different singers never sing the same song exactly alike, nevertheless a singer will protest that he can do his own version of a song line for line and word for word any time, and indeed, ‘just the same twenty years from now’ (Lord 1960, p. 27). When, however, their purported verbatim renditions are recorded and compared, they turn out to be never the same, though the songs are recognizable versions of the same story. ‘Word for word and line for line’, as Lord interprets (1960, p. 28), is simply an emphatic way of saying ‘like’."

 
discretisation of words belongs to writing. orality had no sense of this

"The sense of individual words as significantly discrete items is fostered by writing, which, here as elsewhere, is diaeretic, separative. (Early manuscripts tend not to separate words clearly from each other, but to run them together.)"

 
orality misunderstands the literate and vice versa

"Significantly, illiterate singers in the widely literate culture of mod-ern former Yugoslavia develop and express attitudes toward writing (Lord 1960, p. 28). They admire literacy and believe that a literate person can do even better what they do, namely, recreate a lengthy song after hearing it only once. This is precisely what literates cannot do, or can do only with difficulty. As literates attribute literate kinds of achievement to oral performers, so oral performers attribute oral kinds of achievement to literates."

 
literates and orality based people act differentltcwith scizophrenia

"An example of the contrast between orality and literacy on these grounds is found in Carother’s report (1959) of evidence that oral peoples commonly externalize schizoid behavior where literates interiorize it. Literates often manifest tendencies (loss of contact with environment) by psychic withdrawal into a dreamworld of their own (schizophrenic delusional systematization), oral folk commonly manifest their schizoid tendencies by extreme external confusion, leading often to violent action, including mutilation of the self and of others. This behavior is frequent enough to have given rise to special terms to designate it: the old-time Scandinavian warrior going ‘berserk’, the Southeast Asian person running ‘amok’."

 
the presence of the word

"have treated the matter in greater fullness and depth in The Presence of the Word, to which the interested reader is referred (1967b, Index)."

 
vision dissects, sound incorporates. D Ihde wrote a similar thing about how sound helps us imagine the context of a box

"Hearing can register interiority without violating it. I can rap a box to find whether it is empty or full or a wall to find whether it is hollow or solid inside. Or I can ring a coin to learn whether it is silver or lead. Sounds all register the interior structures of whatever it is that produces them. A violin filled with concrete will not sound like a normal violin. A saxophone sounds differently from a flute: it is structured differently inside. And above all, the human voice comes from inside the human organism which provides the voice’s resonances. Sight isolates, sound incorporates. Whereas sight situates the observer outside what he views, at a distance, sound pours into the hearer. Vision dissects, as Merleau-Ponty has observed (1961)."

 
only true in part. hearing can also isolate

"By contrast with vision, the dissecting sense, sound is thus a unifying sense. A typical visual ideal is clarity and distinctness, a taking apart (Descartes’ campaigning for clarity and distinctness registered an intensification of vision in the human sensorium – Ong 1967b, pp. 63, 221). The auditory ideal, by contrast, is harmony, a putting together."

 
embodiment cannot be understood mathematically

"It should be noted that the concepts interior and exterior are not mathematical concepts and cannot be differentiated mathematically. They are existentially grounded concepts, based on experience of one’s own body, which is both inside me (I do not ask you to stop kicking my body but to stop kicking me ) and outside me (I feel myself as in some sense inside my body). The body is a frontier between myself and everything else. What we mean by ‘interior’ and ‘exterior’ can be conveyed only by reference to experience of bodiliness. Attempted definitions of ‘interior’ and ‘exterior’ are inevitably tautological: ‘interior’ is defined by ‘in’, which is defined by ‘between’, which is defined by ‘inside’, and so on round and round the tautological circle. The same is true with ‘exterior’. When we speak of interior and exterior, even in the case of physical objects, we are referring to our own sense of ourselves: I am inside here and everything else is outside. By interior and exterior we point to our own experience of bodiliness (Ong 1967b, pp. 117–22, 176–9, 228, 231) and analyze other objects by reference to this experience."

 
primarily oral cultures center themselves, because sound is a more important sense

"In a primary oral culture, where the word has its existence only in sound, with no reference whatsoever to any visually perceptible text, and no awareness of even the possibility of such a text, the phenomenology of sound enters deeply into human beings’ feel for existence, as processed by the spoken word. For the way in which the word is experienced is always momentous in psychic life. The centering action of sound (the field of sound is not spread out before me but is all around me) affects man’s sense of the cosmos. For oral cultures, the cosmos is an ongoing event with man at its center. Man is the umbilicus mundi, the navel of the world (Eliade 1958, pp. 231–5, etc.). Only after print and the extensive experience with maps that print implemented would human beings, when they thought about the cosmos or universe or ‘world’, think primarily of something laid out before their eyes, as in a modern printed atlas, a vast surface or assemblage of surfaces (vision presents surfaces) ready to be ‘explored’. The ancient oral world knew few ‘explorers’, though it did know many itinerants, travelers, voyagers, adventurers, and pilgrims."

 
the primary oral world

"It will be seen that most of the characteristics of orally based thought and expression discussed earlier in this chapter relate intimately to the unifying, centralizing, interiorizing economy of sound as perceived by human beings. A sound-dominated verbal economy is consonant with aggregative (harmonizing) tendencies rather than with analytic, dissecting tendencies (which would come with the inscribed, visualized word: vision is a dissecting sense). It is consonant also with the conservative holism (the homeostatic present that must be kept intact, the formulary expressions that must be kept intact), with situational thinking (again holistic, with human action at the center) rather than abstract thinking, with a certain humanistic organization of knowledge around the actions of human and anthropomorphic beings, interiorized persons, rather than around impersonal things."

 
when people read their claude slides i feel none of this, in spite of the uttering the words, they feel hollow to me

"Because in its physical constitution as sound, the spoken word proceeds from the human interior and manifests human beings to one another as conscious interiors, as persons, the spoken word forms human beings into close-knit groups. When a speaker is addressing an audience, the members of the audience normally become a unity, with themselves and with the speaker. If"

 
thought is nested in speech writing is about communicating - ensuring no bad ambiguity which will confuse others

"Jacques Derrida has made the point that ‘there is no linguistic sign before writing’ (1976, p. 14). But neither is there a linguistic ‘sign’ after writing if the oral reference of the written text is adverted to. Though it releases unheard-of potentials of the word, a textual, visual representation of a word is not a real word, but a ‘secondary modeling system’ (cf. Lotman 1977). Thought is nested in speech, not in texts, all of which have their meanings through reference of the visible symbol to the world of sound. What the reader is seeing on this page are not real words but coded symbols whereby a properly informed human being can evoke in his or her consciousness real words, in actual or imagined sound. It is impossible for script to be more than marks on a surface unless it is used by a conscious human being as a cue to sounded words, real or imagined, directly or indirectly."

 
winged words for llms? if we do not grasp them well snd theyre often used incorrectly by llms, then the winged words are back

"Oral man is not so likely to think of words as ‘signs’, quiescent visual phenomena. Homer refers to them with the standard epithet ‘winged words’ – which suggests evanescence, power, and freedom: words are constantly moving, but by flight, which is a powerful form of movement, and one lifting the flier free of the ordinary, gross, heavy, ‘objective’ world."

 
thought processes and llms of course we might consider this to be natural in stieglers sense

"A deeper understanding of pristine or primary orality enables us better to understand the new world of writing, what it truly is, and what functionally literate human beings really are: beings whose thought processes do not grow out of simply natural powers but out of these powers as structured, directly or indirectly, by the technology of writing. Without writing, the literate mind would not and could not think as it does, not only when engaged in writing but normally even when it is composing its thoughts in oral form. More than any other single invention, writing has transformed human consciousness."

 
what about llms and context free language

"Writing establishes what has been called ‘context-free’ language (Hirsch 1977, pp. 21–3, 26) or ‘autonomous’ discourse (Olson 1980a), discourse which cannot be directly questioned or contested as oral speech can be because written discourse has been detached from its author."

 
an llm doesnt always say the same thing. the book is burned again and again.. claude says...

"The author might be challenged if only he or she could be reached, but the author cannot be reached in any book. There is no way directly to refute a text. After absolutely total and devastating refutation, it says exactly the same thing as before. This is one reason why ‘the book says’ is popularly tantamount to ‘it is true’. It is also one reason why books have been burnt. A text stating what the whole world knows is false will state falsehood forever, so long as the text exists. Texts are inherently contumacious."

 
relates to what we should value

"Plato’s philosophically analytic thought, as has been seen (Havelock 1963), including his critique of writing, was possible only because of the effects that writing was beginning to have on mental processes."

 
havelock and plato a victim of his own psyche

"In fact, as Havelock has beautifully shown (1963), Plato’s entire epistemology was unwittingly a programmed rejection of the old oral, mobile, warm, personally interactive lifeworld of oral culture (represented by the poets, whom he would not allow in his Republic). The term idea, form, is visually based, coming from the same root as the Latin video, to see, and such English derivatives as vision, visible, or videotape. Platonic form was form conceived of by analogy with visible form. The Platonic ideas are voiceless, immobile, devoid of all warmth, not interactive but isolated, not part of the human lifeworld at all but utterly above and beyond it. Plato of course was not at all fully aware of the unconscious forces at work in his psyche to produce this reaction, or overreaction, of the literate person to lingering, retardant orality."

 
transformation of human consciousnesss

"modern knowledge (1900– date), where, according to the Ong line of thought, writing and print-literacy have “transformed” human consciousness as a whole, while a “secondary orality” has emerged with digital media."

 
on francis bacon

"was Sir Francis Bacon (1605), founding philosopher of modern empirical science (dubbed by some the “father of inductive reasoning”),6 and urgent advocate of the “advancement of learning,” who tried to classify knowledge on the basis of the relationship between forms of communication and human faculties. As Diana Altegoer writes: “Bacon claimed that all human learning flows from the three fountains of memory, imagination and reason, from which emanate history, poesy, and philosophy ; there can be no others” (Altegoer 2000: 22). Bacon saw what he called “the faculties of the mind of man” as of two kinds: “the one respecting his understanding and reason, and the other his will, appetite, and a affection ”; and it was imagination that acted as an “agent or nuntius” [messenger] between the two (Bacon 1605: Book II, section XII). Thus, “poesy, aligned with the imagination, held a pivotal place in Bacon’s scheme to advance learning; by linking reason with the will and appetite” (Altegoer 2000: 22)."

 
do LLMs restructure consciousness?

"Ong’s work was an early example of what is now called the “science of science” – an investigation not into what but how we know. Along with his contemporary, Marshall McLuhan,8 who coined the slogan “the medium is the message,” Ong popularised the idea that knowledge is a product of language, and that the medium in which language is communicated – by voice, writing, print – makes us think along certain path-dependent lines. Ong went further: he contended that “writing restructures consciousness ” ( Orality and Literacy: Chapter 4)."

 
ongismc- what and how

"Thus “Ongism” is the place where mind is determined by medium. Methodologically, it uses linguistic analysis – something that “from the time of the medieval scholastics, the Anglo-Saxon world has been generating a good deal of thought around” (Ong 1958: 4). Such analysis reconnects rhetoric with science (knowledge)."

 
tech alters how we think, reflect. aoso psychologically - see artificial intimacy

"Such considerations alert us to the paradoxes that beset the relationships between the original spoken word and all its technological transformations. The reason for the tantalizing involutions here is obviously that intelligence is relentlessly reflexive, so that even the external tools that it uses to implement its workings become ‘internalized’, that is, part of its own reflexive process."

 
paradox of writing

"One of the most startling paradoxes inherent in writing is its close association with death. This association is suggested in Plato’s charge that writing is inhuman, thing-like, and that it destroys memory. It is also abundantly evident in countless references to writing (and/or print) traceable in printed dictionaries of quotations, from 2 Corinthians 3:6, ‘The letter kills but the spirit gives life’ and Horace’s reference to his three books of Odes as a ‘monument’ ( Odes iii.30. 1), presaging his own death, on to and beyond Henry Vaughan’s assurance to Sir Thomas Bodley that in the Bodleian Library at Oxford ‘every book is thy epitaph’. In Pippa Passes, Robert Browning calls attention to the still widespread practice of pressing living flowers to death between the pages of printed books, ‘faded yellow blossoms/twixt page and page’. The dead flower, once alive, is the psychic equivalent of the verbal text. The paradox lies in the fact that the deadness of the text, its removal from the living human lifeworld, its rigid visual fixity, assures its endurance and its potential for being resurrected into limitless living contexts by a potentially infinite number of living readers (Ong 1977, pp. 230–71)."

 
is it not faulty to think of writing as a separate thing? today most people use or consume writing through computers, and so perhaps they should be examined as one system. all writing is not equal at all. writing as organology?

"Writing is in a way the most drastic of the three technologies. It initiated what print and computers only continue, the reduction of dynamic sound to quiescent space, the separation of the word from the living present, where alone spoken words can exist."

 
interior transformations through technologies. now we have a bit more than distance, though

"To say writing is artificial is not to condemn it but to praise it. Like other artificial creations and indeed more than any other, it is utterly invaluable and indeed essential for the realization of fuller, interior, human potentials. Technologies are not mere exterior aids but also interior transformations of consciousness, and never more than when they affect the word. Such transformations can be uplifting. Writing heightens consciousness. Alienation from a natural milieu can be good for us and indeed is in many ways essential for full human life. To live and to understand fully, we need not only proximity but also distance. This writing provides for consciousness as nothing else does."

 
if properly interiorised. again, today is very different, though i agree with most of thid

"Technologies are artificial, but – paradox again – artificiality is natural to human beings. Technology, properly interiorized, does not degrade human life but on the contrary enhances it. The modern orchestra, for example, is the result of high technology. A violin is an instrument, which is to say a tool. An organ is a huge machine, with sources of power – pumps, bellows, electric generators – totally outside its operator. Beethoven’s score for his Fifth Symphony consists of very careful directions to highly trained technicians, specifying exactly how to use their tools. Legato : do not take your finger off one key until you have hit the next. Staccato : hit the key and take your finger off immediately. And so on. As musicologists well know, it is pointless to object to electronic compositions such as Morton Subotnik’s The Wild Bull on the grounds that the sounds come out of a mechanical contrivance. What do you think the sounds of an organ come out of? Or the sounds of a violin or even of a whistle? The fact is that by using a mechanical contrivance, a violinist or an organist can express something poignantly human that cannot be expressed without the mechanical contrivance. To achieve such expression of course the violinist or organist has to have interiorized the technology, made the tool or machine a second nature, a psychological part of himself or herself. This calls for years of ‘practice’, learning how to make the tool do what it can do. Such shaping of a tool to oneself, learning a technological skill, is hardly dehumanizing. The use of a technology can enrich the human psyche, enlarge the human spirit, intensify its interior life. Writing is an even more deeply interiorized technology than instrumental musical performance is. But to understand what it is, which means to understand it in relation to its past, to orality, the fact that it is a technology must be honestly faced."

 
what we mean by writing

"The critical and unique breakthrough into new worlds of knowledge was achieved within human consciousness not when simple semiotic marking was devised but when a coded system of visible marks was invented whereby a writer could determine the exact words that the reader would generate from the text. This is what we usually mean today by writing in its sharply focused sense."

 
there can be no doubt, eh?

"There can be no doubt that the characters will be replaced by the roman alphabet as soon as all the people in the People’s Republic of China master the same Chinese language (‘dialect’), the Mandarin now being taught everywhere. The loss to literature will be enormous, but not so enormous as a Chinese typewriter using over 40,000 characters."

 
greek language favours analytic thought

"It appears that the structure of the Greek language, the fact that it was not based on a system like the Semitic that was hospitable to omission of vowels from writing, turned out to be a perhaps accidental but crucial intellectual advantage. Kerckhove (1981) has suggested that, more than other writing systems, the completely phonetic alphabet favors left-hemisphere activity in the brain, and thus on neurophysiological grounds fosters abstract, analytic thought."

 
democratisation of writing.

"Only around Plato’s time in ancient Greece, more than three centuries after the introduction of the Greek alphabet, was this stage transcended when writing was finally diffused through the Greek population and interiorized enough to affect thought processes generally (Havelock 1963)."

 
the whole body labors

"Longstanding oral mental habits of thinking through one’s thoughts aloud encourage dictation, but so did the state of writing technology. In the physical act of writing, the medieval Englishman Orderic Vitalis says, ‘the whole body labors’ (Clanchy 1979, p. 90)."

 
documents did not immediatdly inspire trust

"In the period he studies, Clanchy finds that ‘documents did not immediately inspire trust’ (Clanchy 1979, p. 230). People had to be persuaded that writing improved the old oral methods sufficiently to warrant all the expense and troublesome techniques it involved. Before the use of documents, collective oral testimony was commonly used to establish, for example, the age of feudal heirs."

 
computed time is convenient, but also dangerous

"gifts. Early charters conveying land in England were originally not even dated (1979, pp. 231, 236–41), probably for a variety of reasons. Clanchy suggests that the most profound reason was probably that ‘dating required the scribe to express an opinion about his place in time’ (1979, p. 238), which demanded that he choose a point of reference. What point? Was he to locate this document by reference to the creation of the world? To the Crucifixion? To the birth of Christ? Popes dated documents this way, from Christ’s birth, but was it presumptuous to date a secular document as popes dated theirs? In high technology cultures today, everyone lives each day in a frame of abstract computed time enforced by millions of printed calendars, clocks, and watches. In twelfth-century England there were no clocks or watches or wall or desk calendars. Before writing was deeply interiorized by print, people did not feel themselves situated every moment of their lives in abstract computed time of any sort. It appears unlikely that most persons in medieval or even Renaissance western Europe would ordinarily have been aware of the number of the current calendar year – from the birth of Christ or any other point in the past. Why should they be? Indecision concerning what point to compute from attested the trivialities of the issue. In a culture with no newspapers or other currently dated material to impinge on consciousness, what would be the point for most people in knowing the current calendar year? The abstract calendar number would relate to nothing in real life. Most persons did not know and never even tried to discover in what calendar year they had been born. Moreover"

 
orality knows no lists or charts or figures

"The verifiable errors resulting from the still radically oral economic and juridical procedures that Clanchy reports were minimal because the fuller past was mostly inaccessible to consciousness. ‘Remembered truth was... flexible and up to date’ (Clanchy 1979, p. 233). As has been seen in instances from modern Nigeria and Ghana (Goody and Watt 1968, pp. 31–4), in an oral economy of thought, matters from the past without any sort of present relevance commonly dropped into oblivion. Customary law, trimmed of material no longer of use, was automatically always up to date and thus youthful – a fact which, paradoxically, makes customary law seem inevitable and thus very old (cf. Clanchy 1979, p. 233). Persons whose world view has been formed by high literacy need to remind themselves that in functionally oral cultures the past is not felt as an itemized terrain, peppered with verifiable and disputed ‘facts’ or bits of information. It is the domain of the ancestors, a resonant source for renewing awareness of present existence, which itself is not an itemized terrain either. Orality knows no lists or charts or figures."

 
lists used narrative, easier to remember

"Even genealogies out of such orally framed tradition are in effect commonly narrative. Instead of a recitation of names, we find a sequence of ‘begats’, of statements of what someone did: ‘Irad begat Mehajael, Mehajael begat Methusael, Methusael begat Lamech’ (Genesis 4:18). This sort of aggregation derives partly from the oral drive to use formulas, partly from the oral mnemonic drive to exploit balance (recurrence of subject-predicate-object produces a swing which aids recall and which a mere sequence of names would lack), partly from the oral drive to redundancy (each person is mentioned twice, as begetter and begotten), and partly from the oral drive to narrate rather than simply to juxtapose (the persons are not immobilized as in a police line-up, but are doing something – namely, begetting)."

 
metaphor guides documents

"Lists of the sort Goody discusses are of course useful if we are reflectively aware of the distortion they inevitably introduce. Visual presentation of verbalized material in space has its own particular economy, its own laws of motion and structure. Texts in various scripts around the world are read variously from right to left, or left to right, or top to bottom, or all these ways at once as in boustrophedon writing, but never anywhere, so far as is known, from bottom to top. Texts assimilate utterance to the human body. They introduce a feeling for ‘headings’ in accumulations of knowledge: ‘chapter’ derives from the Latin caput, meaning head (as of the human body). Pages have not only ‘heads’ but also ‘feet’, for footnotes. References are given to what is ‘above’ and ‘below’ in a text when what is meant is several pages back or farther on. The significance of the vertical and the horizontal in texts deserves serious study. Kerckhove (1981) suggests that growth in lefthemisphere dominance governed the drift in early Greek writing from right-to-left movement, to boustrophedon movement (‘ox-plowing’ pattern, one line going right, then a turn around a corner into the next line going left, the letters inverted according to the direction of the line), to stoichedon style (vertical lines), and finally to definitive leftto-right movement on a horizontal line. All this is quite a different world of order from anything in the oral sensibility, which has no way of operating with ‘headings’ or verbal linearity. Across the world the alphabet, the ruthlessly efficient reducer of sound to space, is pressed into direct service for setting up the new space-defined sequences: items are marked a, b, c, and so on to indicate their sequences, and even poems in the early days of literacy are composed with the first letter of the first word of successive lines following the order of the alphabet. The alphabet as a simple sequence of letters is a major bridge between oral mnemonic and literate mnemonics: generally the sequence of the letters of the alphabet is memorized orally and then used for largely visual retrieval of materials, as in indexes."

 
because spokem words are phenomenally embodied

"The condition of words in a text is quite different from their condition in spoken discourse. Although they refer to sounds and are meaningless unless they can be related – externally or in the imagination – to the sounds or, more precisely, the phonemes they encode, written words are isolated from the fuller context in which spoken words come into being. The word in its natural, oral habitat is a part of a real, existential present. Spoken utterance is addressed by a real, living person to another real, living person or real, living persons, at a specific time in a real setting which includes always much more than mere words. Spoken words are always modifications of a total situation which is more than verbal. They never occur alone, in a context simply of words."

 
still the case?

"Extratextual context is missing not only for readers but also for the writer. Lack of verifiable context is what makes writing normally so much more agonizing an activity than oral presentation to a real audience. ‘The writer’s audience is always a fiction’ (Ong 1977, pp. 53–81)."

 
ironic growth of writing tradition

"There is no mimesis here in Aristotle’s sense, except ironically. Writing is indeed the seedbed of irony, and the longer the writing (and print) tradition endures, the heavier the ironic growth becomes (Ong 1977, pp. 272–302)."

 
orality is not known for analytic precision, but it is not a quality inherenr to writing, it is merely made possible by writing. it is again the pharmakon, in which way we can view LLMs as an alteration of the very nature of writing.

"The distancing which writing effects develops a new kind of precision in verbalization by removing it from the rich but chaotic existential context of much oral utterance. Oral performances can be impressive in their magniloquence and communal wisdom, whether they are lengthy, as in formal narrative, or brief and apophthegmatic, as in proverbs. Yet wisdom has to do with a total and relatively infrangible social context. Orally managed language and thought are not noted for analytic precision."

 
but llms cannot do this, which is why their words often are hollow beyond anything a human can produce. although humans can also produce hollow writing when they write on smth they do not understand

"Of course, all language and thought are to some degree analytic: they break down the dense continuum of experience, William James’s ‘big, blooming, buzzing confusion’, into more or less separate parts, meaningful segments."

 
writing is agonosing, in order to communicate what we want to communicate. sometimes that means eliminating ambiguity, othertimes not

"But written words sharpen analysis, for the individual words are called on to do more. To make yourself clear without gesture, without facial expression, without intonation, without a real hearer, you have to foresee circumspectly all possible meanings a statement may have for any possible reader in any possible situation, and you have to make your language work so as to come clear all by itself, with no existential context. The need for this exquisite circumspection makes writing the agonizing work it commonly is. What Goody (1977, p. 128) calls ‘backward scanning’ makes it possible in writing to eliminate inconsistencies (Goody 1977, pp. 49–50), to choose between words with a reflective selectivity that invests thought and words with new discriminatory powers."

 
minds shaped by writing as it was... the effort spent reading and writing deeply are indeed efforts required for sharper minds and to maintain the alleged goals of our society and education. the outcome is slower, but more precise, better

"The exquisitely analytic oral disputations in medieval universities and in later scholastic tradition into the present century (Ong 1981, pp. 137–8) were the work of minds honed by writing texts and by reading and commenting on texts, orally and in writing."

 
increased introspection

"By separating the knower from the known (Havelock 1963), writing makes possible increasingly articulate introspectivity, opening the psyche as never before not only to the external objective world quite distinct from itself but also to the interior self against whom the objective world is set."

 
at least with writing taught in a certain way at a different time.

"The group Bernstein found using this code were from the six major public schools that provided the most intensive education in reading and writing in Britain (1974, p. 83). Bernstein’s ‘restricted’ and ‘elaborated’ linguistic codes could be relabeled ‘oralbased’ and ‘text-based’ codes respectively. Olson (1977) has shown how orality relegates meaning largely to context whereas writing concentrates meaning in language itself."

 
grapholect

"As Guxman has pointed out (1970, pp. 773–6), a national written language has had to be isolated from its original dialect base, has discarded certain dialectal forms, has developed various layers of vocabulary from sources not dialectal at all, and has developed also certain syntactical peculiarities. This kind of established written language Haugen (1966, pp. 50–71) has aptly styled a ‘grapholect’."

 
llms made possible on this, but will erase its very value by dillution and impoverishing

"The grapholect bears the marks of the millions of minds which have used it to share their consciousnesses with one another. Into it has been hammered a massive vocabulary of an order of magnitude impossible for an oral tongue"

 
llms omit grapholect and in a sense bring about faulty dialects that heavy users are increasingly suspect in adopting, which in turn renders them decreasingly capable of understsnding the grapholect, which Hirsch deems important

"Where grapholects exist, ‘correct’ grammar and usage are popularly interpreted as the grammar and usage of the grapholect itself to the exclusion of the grammar and usage of other dialects. The sensory bases of the very concept of order are largely visual (Ong 1967b, pp. 108, 136–7), and the fact that the grapholect is written or, a fortiori, printed encourages attributing to it a special normative power for keeping language in order. But when other dialects of a given language besides the grapholect vary from the grammar of the grapholect, they are not ungrammatical: they are simply using a different grammar, for language is structure, and it is impossible to use language without a grammar. In the light of this fact, linguists today commonly make the point that all dialects are equal in the sense that none has a grammar intrinsically more ‘correct’ than that of others. But Hirsch (1977, pp. 43–50) makes the further point that in a profound sense no other dialect, for example, in English or German or Italian, has anything remotely like the resources of the grapholect. It is bad pedagogy to insist that because there is nothing ‘wrong’ with other dialects, it makes no difference whether or not speakers of another dialect learn the grapholect, which has resources of a totally different order of magnitude."

 
but likewise written expertise is not equal to tacit knowledge

"Homeric and the pre-Homeric Greeks, like oral peoples generally, practiced public speaking with great skill long before their skills were reduced to an ‘art’, that is, to a body of sequentially organized, scientific principles which explained and abetted what verbal persuasion consisted in. Such an ‘art’ is presented in Aristotle’s Art of Rhetoric ( techn rhtorik ). Oral cultures, as has been seen, can have no ‘arts’ of this scientifically organized sort. No one could or can simply recite extempore a treatise such as Aristotle’s Art of Rhetoric, as someone in an oral culture would have to do if this sort of understanding were to be implemented. Lengthy oral productions follow more agglomerative, less analytic, patterns. The ‘art’ of rhetoric, though concerned with oral speech, was, like other ‘arts’, the product of writing."

 
agonistic heritage

"With its agonistic heritage, rhetorical teaching assumed that the aim of more or less all discourse was to prove or disprove a point, against some opposition. Developing a subject was thought of as a process of ‘invention’, that is, of finding in the store of arguments that others had always exploited those arguments which were applicable to your case. These arguments were considered to be lodged or ‘seated’ (Quintilian’s term) in the ‘places’ ( topoi in Greek, loci in Latin), and were often called the loci communes or commonplaces when they were thought of as providing arguments common to any and all subject matter."

 
llm translation is often transformation

"Interaction between such a chirographically controlled language as Learned Latin and the various vernaculars (mother tongues) is still far from being completely understood. There is no way simply to ‘translate’ a language such as Learned Latin into languages like the vernaculars. Translation was transformation. Interaction produced all sorts of special results. Bäuml (1980, p. 264) has called attention, for example, to some of the effects when metaphors from a consciously metaphorical Latin were shifted into less metaphoricized mother tongues."

 
as writing has lost its chirography, so has it lost some of its strength, which was in its strictness. the elitism here is a pharmakon - it serves to uphold a level of rigidity in the language, but at the cost of accessibility and democratisation. Democratisation viewed purely as access is what AI products are selling, but it serves the same purpose of reducing the quality of its output and people's general perception of it by making it essy to produce. similar to device paradigm

"All languages used for learned discourse today are also mother tongues (or, in the case of Arabic, are more and more assimilating to themselves mother tongues). Nothing shows more convincingly than this disappearance of chirographically controlled language how writing is losing its earlier power monopoly (though not its importance) in today’s world."

 
clesrly missing today. the orality of rhetoric disappeared naturally

"Once it was completed, rhetoric was no longer the allpervasive subject it had once been: education could no longer be described as fundamentally rhetorical as it could be in past ages. The three R s – reading, ’riting, and ’rithmetic – representing an essentially nonrhetorical, bookish, commercial and domestic education, gradually took over from the traditional orally grounded, heroic, agonistic education that had generally prepared young men in the past for teaching and professional, ecclesiastical, or political public service. In the process, as rhetoric and Latin went out, women entered more and more into academia, which also became more and more commercially oriented (Ong 1967b, pp. 241–55)."

 
llms suggest that words are nothing

"Print suggests that words are things far more than writing ever did."

 
llms as epistemic tools

"Before the mid-1400s the Koreans and Uigur Turks had both the alphabet and movable type, but the movable types bore not separate letters but whole words. Alphabet letterpress printing, in which each letter was cast on a separate piece of metal, or type, marked a psychological breakthrough of the first order. It embedded the word itself deeply in the manufacturing process and made it into a kind of commodity. The"

 
print reified the word

"Despite the assumptions of many semiotic structuralists, it was print, not writing, that effectively reified the word, and, with it, noetic activity (Ong 1958b, pp. 306–18)."

 
what is the voice of AI to different people?

"By and large, printed texts are far easier to read than manuscript texts. The effects of the greater legibility of print are massive. The greater legibility ultimately makes for rapid, silent reading. Such reading in turn makes for a different relationship between the reader and the authorial voice in the text and calls for different styles of writing."

 
description changed drastically with print

"The availability of carefully made, technical prints (first woodcuts, and later even more exactly detailed metal engravings) implemented such exactly worded descriptions. Technical prints and technical verbalization reinforced and improved each other. The resulting hypervisualized noetic world was brand new. Ancient and medieval writers are simply unable to produce exactly worded descriptions of complex objects at all approximating the descriptions that appear after print and, indeed, that mature chiefly with the Age of Romanticism, that is, the age of the Industrial Revolution. Oral and residually oral verbalization directs its attention to action, not to the visual appearance of objects or scenes or persons (Fritschi 1981, pp. 65–6; cf. Havelock 1963, pp. 61–96)."

 
no word on what is lost in this?

"One can list without end additional effects, more or less direct, which print had on the noetic economy or the ‘mentality’ of the West. Print eventually removed the ancient art of (orally based) rhetoric from the center of academic education. It encouraged and made possible on a large scale the quantification of knowledge, both through the use of mathematical analysis and through the use of diagrams and charts."

 
do llms democratise? output (only llm output), not skill. not respect or astonishment

"Typography had made the word into a commodity. The old communal oral world had split up into privately claimed free holdings. The drift in human consciousness toward greater individualism had been served well by print."

 
individuals more possesive - inert personal space

"By removing words from the world of sound where they had first had their origin in active human interchange and relegating them definitively to visual surface, and by otherwise exploiting visual space for the management of knowledge, print encouraged human beings to think of their own interior conscious and unconscious resources as more and more thing-like, impersonal and religiously neutral. Print encouraged the mind to sense that its possessions were held in some sort of inert mental space."

 
llm anxiety

"They were all the more disquieting because modern writers, agonizingly aware of literary history and of the de facto intertextuality of their own works, are concerned that they may be producing nothing really new or fresh at all, that they maybe totally under the ‘influence’ of others’ texts. Harold Bloom’s work The Anxiety of Influence (1973) treats this modern writer’s anguish. Manuscript cultures had few if any anxieties about influence to plague them, and oral cultures had virtually none."

 
global village. mcluhan

"But secondary orality generates a sense for groups immeasurably larger than those of primary oral culture – McLuhan’s ‘global village’."

 
turning inward again?

"The individual feels that he or she, as an individual, must be socially sensitive. Unlike members of a primary oral culture, who are turned outward because they have had little occasion to turn inward, we are turned outward because we have turned inward."

 
do llms change this?

"The effects of literacy and later of print on the plotting of narrative are too vast to treat here in full detail. But some of the more generic effects are illuminated by considering the transit to literacy from orality. As the experience of working with text as text matures, the maker of the text, now properly an ‘author’, acquires a feeling for expression and organization notably different from that of the oral performer before a live audience. The ‘author’ can read the stories of others in solitude, can work from notes, can even outline a story in advance of writing it. Though inspiration continues to derive from unconscious sources, the writer can subject the unconscious inspiration to far greater conscious control than the oral narrator. The writer finds his written words accessible for reconsideration, revision, and other manipulation until they are finally released to do their work. Under the author’s eyes the text lays out the beginning, the middle and the end, so that the writer is encouraged to think of his work as a self-contained, discrete unit, defined by closure."

 
writing heightens consciousness, but we do not write anymore

"Writing, as has been seen, is essentially a consciousness-raising activity. The tightly organized, classically plotted story both results from and encourages heightened consciousness, and this fact expresses itself symbolically when, with the arrival of the perfectly pyramidal plot in the detective story, the action is seen to be focused within the consciousness of the protagonist – the detective. In recent decades, as typographic culture has been transmuted into electronic culture, the tightly plotted story has fallen out of favor as too ‘easy’ (that is, too fully controlled by consciousness) for author and reader. Avantgarde literature is now obliged to deplot its narratives or to obscure their plots. But deplotted stories of the electronic age are not episodic narratives. They are impressionistic and imagistic variations on the plotted stories that preceded them. Narrative plot now permanently bears the mark of writing and typography. When it structures itself in memories and echoes, suggestive of early primary oral narrative with its heavy reliance on the unconscious (Peabody 1975), it does so inevitably in a self-conscious, characteristically literate way, as in Alain Robbe-Grillet’s La Jalousie or James Joyce’s Ulysses."

 
increased reflection from writing

"Watt (1967, p. 75) calls attention to the ‘internalization of conscience’ and the introspective habits that produced the feeling for human character found already in Defoe, and traces this to Defoe’s Calvinist Puritan background. There is something distinctively Calvinistic in the way Defoe’s introspective characters relate to the secular world. But introspection and greater and greater internalization of conscience mark the entire history of Christian asceticism, where their intensification is clearly connected with writing, from St Augustine’s Confessions to the Autobiography of St Thérèse of Lisieux (1873–97)."

 
writing is strenuous. good

"Writing and reading, as has been seen, are solo activities (though reading at first was often enough done communally). They engage the psyche in strenuous, interiorized, individualized thought of a sort inaccessible to oral folk. In the private worlds that they generate, the feeling for the ‘round’ human character is born – deeply interiorized in motivation, powered mysteriously, but consistently, from within. First emerging in chirographically controlled ancient Greek drama, the ‘round’ character is further developed in Shakespeare’s age after the coming of print, and comes to its peak with the novel, when, after the advent of the Age of Romanticism, print is more fully interiorized (Ong 1971)."

 
writing allowed accumulation, thus the way we are phenomenally conscious today. do llms allow accumulation in the same way, or does it really hinder it? it both alters how we contribute to our tertiary retention, but also how capable we are of doing so

"But whatever these other forces behind the development of depth psychology, one major force was the new feeling for the human lifeworld and the human person occasioned by writing and print. Epithetically delineated characters do not yield well to psychoanalytic criticism, nor do characters delineated in a faculty psychology of competing ‘virtues’ and ‘vices’. Insofar as modern psychology and the ‘round’ character of fiction represent to present-day consciousness what human existence is like, the feeling for human existence has been processed through writing and print. This is by no means to fault the present-day feeling for human existence. Quite the contrary. The present-day phenomenological sense of existence is richer in its conscious and articulate reflection than anything that preceded it. But it is salutary to recognize that this sense depends on the technologies of writing and print, deeply interiorized, made a part of our own psychic resources. The tremendous store of historical, psychological and other knowledge which can go into sophisticated narrative and characterization today could be accumulated only through the use of writing and print (and now electronics). But these technologies of the word do not merely store what we know. They style what we know in ways which made it quite inaccessible and indeed unthinkable in an oral culture."

 
make it fit

"Attention to such work would add another dimension to Structuralist analysis, which is often accused of being overly abstract and tendentious – all structures discerned turn out to be binary (we live in the age of the computer), and binarism is achieved by passing over elements, often crucial elements, that do not fit binary patterning. Moreover, the binary structures, however interesting the abstract patterns they form, seem not to explain the psychological urgency of a narrative and thus they fail to account for why the story is a story."

 
same for instrumentalists

"Oral performers, especially but not exclusively performers in verse, are beset with distractions. A word may set off a chain of associations which the performer follows into a cul de sac from which only the skilled narrator can extricate himself. Homer gets himself into such predicaments not infrequently – ‘Homer nods’. The ability to correct mistakes gracefully and make them appear as not mistakes at all is one of the things that separates the expert singers from the bunglers (Peabody 1975, pp. 235, 457–64; Lord 1960, p. 109)."

 
derrida, deconstruction, textualist. writing is not a supplememt to oraliy

"A favorite point of departure for textualists has been Jean-Jacques Rousseau. Jacques Derrida (1976, pp. 164–268 and passim ) has carried on a lengthy dialogue with Rousseau. Derrida insists that writing is ‘not a supplement to the spoken word’ but a quite different perform-ance. By this insistence, he and others have rendered a great service in undercutting the chirographic and typographic bias that has also been the concern of this book. At its worst, as textualists see it, this bias can take this form: one assumes that there simply is a one-to-one correspondence between items in an extramental world and spoken words, and a similar one-to-one correspondence between spoken words and written words (which seem to be taken to include print; the textualists generally assimilate writing and print to each other and seldom if ever venture even to glance at electronic communication). On this assumption of one-to-one correspondence, the naive reader presumes the prior presence of an extramental referent which the word presumably captures and passes on through a kind of pipeline to the psyche."

 
items in the extramental cdont correspond1 to 1 eith spoken words, same with spoken words to writing

"In a variation on Kant’s noumenon-phenomenon theme (itself related to the sight-dominance brought on by writing and confirmed by print – Ong 1967b, p. 74), Derrida excoriates this metaphysics of presence. He styles the pipeline model ‘logocentrism’ and diagnoses it as deriving from ‘phonocentrism’, that is, from taking the logos or sounded word as primary, and thereby debasing writing by comparison with oral speech. Writing breaks the pipeline model because it can be shown that writing has an economy of its own so that it cannot simply transmit unchanged what it receives from speech. Moreover, looking back from the break made by writing, one can see that the pipeline is broken even earlier by spoken words, which do not themselves transmit an extramental world of presence as through transparent glass. Language is structure, and its structure is not that of the extramental world. The end result for Derrida is that literature – and indeed language itself – is not at all ‘representational’ or ‘expressive’ of something outside itself. Since it does not refer to anything in the manner of a pipeline, it refers to, or means, nothing."

 
logocentrism and phonocentrism

"There is little doubt, on the other hand, that today many persons do rely on a logocentric model in thinking about noetic and communication processes. In breaking up what he calls phonocentrism and logocentrism, Derrida is performing a welcome service, in the same territory that Marshall McLuhan swept through with his famous dictum, ‘The medium is the message’."

 
plato actually antipathetic towards old noetic style of the oral folk

"However, recent work on the orality–literacy contrasts treated in the present book complicates the roots of phonocentrism and of logocentrism beyond the textualists’ account, especially in the case of Plato. Plato’s relationship to orality was thoroughly ambiguous. On the one hand, in the Phaedrus and the Seventh Letter he downgraded writing in favor of oral speech, and thus is phonocentric. On the other hand, when, in his Republic, he proscribed poets, he did so, as Havelock shows, because they stood for the old oral, mnemonic world of imitation, aggregative, redundant, copious, traditionalist, warmly human, participatory – a world antipathetic to the analytic, sparse, exact, abstract, visualist, immobile world of the ‘ideas’ which Plato was touting. Plato did not consciously think of his antipathy to poets as an antipathy to the old oral noetic economy, but that is what it was, as we can now discern. Plato felt this antipathy because he lived at the time when the alphabet had first become sufficiently interiorized to affect Greek thought, including his own, the time when patiently analytic, lengthily sequential thought processes were first coming into existence because of the ways in which literacy enabled the mind to process data."

 
language is not consistent, rather ambiguous. an issue for AI

"But why should all the implications suggested by language be consistent? What leads one to believe that language can be so structured as to be perfectly consistent with itself, so as to be a closed system? There are no closed systems and never have been. The illusion that logic is a closed system has been encouraged by writing and even more by print."

 
reader response criticism

"Reader-response criticism is intimately aware that writing and reading differ from oral communication, and in terms of absence: the reader is normally absent when the writer writes and the writer is normally absent when the reader reads, whereas in oral communication speaker and hearer are present to one another."

 
what do llms do to writing?

"Writing created history. What did print do to what writing created? The fuller answer cannot be simply quantitative, in terms of increased ‘facts’. What does the feeling for closure fostered by print have to do with the plotting of historical writing, the selection of the kinds of theme that historians use to break into the seamless web of events around them so that a story can be told? In keeping with the agonistic structures of old oral cultures, early history, though written, was largely the story of wars and political confrontation. Today we have moved to the history of consciousness. This shift in focus here obviously relates to the interiorizing drift in the chirographic mentality. In what ways?"

 
logic itself emerges from writing - to an extent...

"So far as I know, philosophy, and, with it, intellectual history, has done little with orality studies. Philosophy and all the sciences and ‘arts’ (analytic studies of procedures, such as Aristotle’s Art of Rhetoric ) depend for their existence on writing, which is to say they are produced not by the unaided human mind but by the mind making use of a technology that has been deeply interiorized, incorporated into mental processes themselves. The mind interacts with the material world around it more profoundly and creatively than has hitherto been thought. Philosophy, it seems, should be reflectively aware of itself as a technological product – which is to say a special kind of very human product. Logic itself emerges from the technology of writing."

 
what happens when epistemology is carried on by llms

"In sum, if philosophy is reflective about its own nature, what is it to make of the fact that philosophical thinking cannot be carried on by the unaided human mind but only by the human mind that has familiarized itself with and deeply interiorized the technology of writing? What does this precisely intellectual need for technology have to say about the relationship of consciousness to the external universe? And what does it have to say about Marxist theories concentrating on technologies as means of production and alienation? Hegelian philosophy and its sequels are packed with orality–literacy problems. The fuller reflective discovery of the self on which so much of Hegel’s and other phenomenology depends is the result not only of writing but also of print: without these technologies the modern privatization of the self and the modern acute, doubly reflexive self-awareness are impossible."

 
relational change.

"To say that a great many changes in the psyche and in culture connect with the passage from orality to writing is not to make writing (and/or its sequel, print) the sole cause of all the changes. The connection is not a matter of reductionism but of relationism. The shift from orality to writing intimately interrelates with more psychic and social developments than we have yet noted. Developments in food production, in trade, in political organization, in religious institutions, in technological skills, in educational practices, in means of transportation, in family organization, and in other areas of human life all play their own distinctive roles. But most of these developments, and indeed very likely every one of them, have themselves been affected, often at great depth, by the shift from orality to literacy and beyond, as many of them have in turn affected this shift."

 
human communication to llms is what

"To speak, you have to address another or others. People in their right minds do not stray through the woods just talking at random to nobody. Even to talk to yourself you have to pretend that you are two people. The reason is that what I say depends on what reality or fancy I feel I am talking into, that is, on what possible responses I might anticipate. Hence I avoid sending quite the same message to an adult and to a small child. To speak, I have to be somehow already in communication with the mind I am to address before I start speaking. I can be in touch perhaps through past relationships, by an exchange of glances, by an understanding with a third person who has brought me and my interlocutor together, or in any of countless other ways. (Words are modifications of a more-than-verbal situation.) I have to sense something in the other’s mind to which my own utterance can relate. Human communication is never one-way. Always, it not only calls for response but is shaped in its very form and content by anticipated response."

 
writi consciousness raising

"Ontogenetically and phylogenetically, it is the oral word that first illuminates consciousness with articulate language, that first divides subject and predicate and then relates them to one another, and that ties human beings to one another in society. Writing introduces division and alienation, but a higher unity as well. It intensifies the sense of self and fosters more conscious interaction between persons. Writing is consciousness-raising."

 
but which kind of reading. how does the television alter consciousness?

"Ong called a “secondary orality” based on electronic media, and simultaneously that: Reading, which was in decline due to the growth of television, tripled from 1980 to 2008, because it is the overwhelmingly preferred way to receive words on the Internet. (Bohn and Short 2010: 7)"

 
outdated

"Some have concluded that his work, and that of Marshall McLuhan, is “technically outdated” (Pettitt 2012), because both of these writers flourished in the analogue era, prior to the social uptake of digital media and the internet."

 
the connected internet is a pharmakon

"Some people now are inclined to nominate the internet, or what John Brockman, self-confessed McLuhanite and founder of The Edge, “the world’s smartest website,”2 calls “Distributed Networked Intelligence (DNI).” That is, not the internet itself, but what the internet enables (i.e. human thought in externalised form): the “collective externalized mind, the mind we all share, the infinite oscillation of our collective consciousness interacting with itself, adding a fuller, richer dimension to what it means to be human” (The Edge 1999; see also Brockman 2012)."

 
farrell

"and by Thomas Farrell, whose extensive writings on Ong must inform any subsequent endeavour (see especially Farrell 2000; and Farrell’s Introduction to Ong 2002: 1–68)."

 
knowledge overreaching itself

"He sees an “antipathy” between the “old oral, mnemonic world of imitation, aggregative, redundant, copious, traditionalist, warmly human, participatory,” and the “analytic, sparse, exact, abstract, visualist, immobile world of [platonic] ‘ideas’” ( Orality and Literacy : 164) that were, he argued, a consequence of alphabetic literacy (scaled up many-fold by print-literacy). This account does not imply a progressive (Whiggish) narrative of technological and cognitive “advance.” There is ample evidence of Ong’s attachment to oral modes; in his hands one might even call them prelapsarian, and speculate that writing, together with its hyperactive progeny, printing, was seen by Ong as another Fall, consequent upon human over-consumption of the tree of knowledge. Ong characterised Ramism as “the final shower of sparks released by an old oral-aural world as it was plunging from the epic firmament into the sea of a typographical civilization” (Ong 2002: 303). This Fall is not that of Judeo-Christian Adam, perhaps, but of Classical Icarus, in a Promethean shower of sparks. Either way, it results from knowledge overreaching itself."

 
history through objects

"Contemporary sensibilities are more “catholic” in their willingness to admit the role of the traditions Ong skates over; and the difficult work of seeking to tell an integrated story of human civilisation as a whole has begun to be attempted. A widely praised example is A History of the World in 100 Objects (MacGregor 2010). This project began life orally, as a spoken radio series, and it continues digitally, as a well-used website.6 Neil MacGregor, director of the British Museum, narrates world history from all inhabited continents and many civilisations. He does this entirely through objects, from the Olduvai stone chopping tools of early hominins, made nearly two million years ago, to a recently made-in-China solar-powered lamp kit."

 
movement to behaviorism

"In the 1950s and 1960s, academic psychology was behaviorist, but mental health practitioners were drawn to psychoanalytic approaches. They got their patients talking about dreams, family histories, characteristic ways of distorting reality in defense against painful truths. What was happening in the profession was mirrored in how everyday people thought about their lives. Even people who had never read Freud or been in therapy talked about the meaning of their dreams and slips of the tongue. But as computers became a commonplace object, with their model of mind as program, they became part of a larger cultural shift to behaviorist thinking—a movement from meaning to mechanism in how people thought about the psyche.14"

Stiegler, B., & Ross, D. (2017). The New Conflict of the Faculties and Functions: Quasi-Causality and Serendipity in the Anthropocene. Qui Parle, 26(1), pp. 79–99.    
Added by: alexb44   Last edited by: alexb44 12/10/2026, 05:29
Knowledge becomes information, and thus automated

"Through the functional and algorithmic integration of the intuition (formatted by data-capturing interfaces), the understanding (the analytic functions of which are delegated to algorithms) and the imagination (which is reconfigured by the automated protentions extracted from the retentions accumulated by “profiles” and provoked by the interactions during which the schematization is itself delegated to the functions of the production of desire, in the sense denounced, wrongly, by Adorno and Horkheimer, as an exteriorization of the imagination, which Kant claimed to be transcendental), what occurs is that the fixed capital of capitalism becomes fully computational, and knowledge, which turns into information, becomes massively automated. This amounts, in other words, to the full realization of the “fragment on machines” in Marx’s Grundrisse."

My italics!

 
Everyday informational practice takes over

"In Technics and Time, 2, I argued that information, in the modern sense that appeared in the nineteenth century with press agencies and telecommunication networks, is first and foremost a commodity that loses value with time—in the course of that time during which it is disseminated into a space where it is broadcast or diffused. This space is also a market, a computational milieu that turns behaviors into inherently calculable objects. Information then becomes a function, and it has “value” only inasmuch as it does so. During the nineteenth century—which will also be that of the appearance of mechanography in North America— the world entered into a process of constant transformation. It entered the Anthropocene as the age of calculated exosomatization, oriented toward what will become permanent innovation (or what Joseph Schumpeter described as creative destruction). The need for psychic individuals and collective individuals to orient themselves within this perpetual becoming, to find the way to a future, requires them to exercise not the faculty of orienting themselves in thought and the world starting from what Kant called the subjective principle of differentiation, but the everyday informational practice that Hegel referred to in Jena between 1803 and 1806. Of course, in Hegel’s time, and despite the “absolute knowledge” to which he aspired and which he intended to embody, the concept of information as function was yet to emerge, and he did not see it coming."

 
"Knowledge" in the new world

"In the new world, which will lead to what is precisely not absolute knowledge but the complete opposite, absolute nonknowledge— that is, computationally and functionally integrated de-noetization (noesis having been functionally disintegrated)—something that informs me is something that matters to me, something of material interest that I had not known, that I was unaware of. From the moment I become “aware” of it, I gain an advantage, an advantage I begin to lose as soon as others also become aware of it and so able to gain the same advantage, which means that no one any longer has any advantage.

Knowledge, then, understood as “being up-to-date,” “being aware,” becomes confounded with “the news” of the new world—and of the “New World.”"

 
Diffusion of knowledge and the value of information

"This is how the question of information and of its value presents itself, and from this we can see that information is the very opposite of knowledge, given that the latter is cumulative, lasting through its transformations (Einstein does not erase Newton, Marx does not eliminate Hegel, etc.). For Charles-Louis Havas in 1835, four yearsafter the death of Hegel, information was worth whatever the newspapers were willing to pay for his dispatches. And the more it is diffused, the less it is worth. Hence is fully established the nihilistic conception of value wherein everything tends toward equivalence— where “everything is the same” and “anything goes.”"

 
On how we disindividuate only to individuate and transform ourselves

"Through what I discover by accident, and as the long-awaited unexpected, I individuate myself: I transform myself “from the ground up,” not so as to produce by calculation a new homeostatic state but, on the contrary, so as to overturn every dimension of my being, leading me to reformulate myself—to adopt new behaviors that are not summable, or comparable, or calculable: they are singularities. Having learned something of the unexpected, I am myself singularly reindividuated, which means that I have bifurcated after having been disindividuated, that I have become no longer comparable to what I had hitherto been, in my having been, in my to ti en einai. This can happen to me through a bullet that lodges in my lower back, as happened to Joë Bousquet, or by alcohol taking hold of my habits, ahappened to Malcolm Lowry: such an individuation by incalculable accidents proceeds step by step according to what Gilles Deleuze called quasi-causality."

 
Tertiary retentions today

"Differing and deferring via what we call information and communication technology, but also via writing, consists in producing tertiary retentions—formerly in a hieratic manner, conducted through sacralization and hierarchization via symbolic, magical, or sacred; then through schools, universities, and academic or scientific powers, aiming to develop forms of knowledge, which are powers to act (first of the polis, then of theologico-political power, and, in the Anthropocene, of capital as the Capitalocene); and, today, through the information industries. The latter tend toward a disruptive takeover of power via control technologies, but in so doing they are heading straight for the wall of a “big shift.” All this makes it imperative to rethink entropy and negentropy in terms that are related to but different from thermodynamics, biology, or the attempted formalizations of cybernetics and the information sciences."

 
Knowledge into systems of information through digital tertiary retention

"This tendency contained in exosomatization is nevertheless perpetually being destroyed by an inverse, anthropic, homogenizing tendency, dictating, to the great noetic diversity that noodiversity forms, obligations to which it must adapt, particularly after capitalism takes hold of Western knowledge to turn it into a function of production and a power of economic domination through calculation and computing. This has tended, ever since the advent of digital tertiary retention, to transform knowledge into systems of information, amounting to the concrete realization of what the “fragment on machines” described as the materialization of automation via the total integration and absorption of knowledge into fixed capital. Yet what this leads to is, in reality, the disintegration of knowledge by absolute nonknowledge."

Tinnell, J. (2015). Grammatization: Bernard Stiegler's theory of writing and technology. Computers and Composition, 37, 132–146.    
Added by: alexb44   Last edited by: Mark Grimshaw-Aagaard 26/09/2026, 09:52
Culture cannot keep up with technology though they're indivisible since all social practices and institutions have a technological basis 

"Simply put, permanent innovation names a historical condition in which technical invention outpaces cultural adaptation (Stiegler, 1998, p. 15). This is not to suggest that technology and culture are divisible; for Stiegler, all social practices and institutions have a technological basis. Precisely because of this interdependence, the adoption of a new cultural technology precipitates the obsolescence, to greater and lesser degrees, of traditions that were developed in conjunction with the affordances of a becoming-obsolete technology. While this sort of technocultural evolution is evident throughout history, technical invention became infused with entirely unprecedented levels of resources and investments starting with the industrial revolution, during which economic incentives abounded to transform scientific knowledge from an academic pursuit into a lucrative industrial research and development enterprise (Stiegler, 1998, p. 40). As such, industrial technical invention has come to outpace conceptual innovation in other social systems such as law, government, and education"

Research turned ito a lucrative industrial research. This is still true with AI, perhaps more than ever, and it (mostly) hides under the guide of doing science that will help humanity as a whole. Importantly, regulation of AI as it is developing shows this very well - it cannot keep up at all.

 
The internet is our collective memory. We do not understand the influence of technics, yet have to make decisions with and about them constantly

"The computer revolution continues to intensify this rift as industrial activities turn toward the production of information technologies that archive, manage, and structure individual and collective memory [my emphasis]. The rapid evolution of global networks increasingly disorients and scrambles the traditions, conventions, and practices that have defined national institutions over previous centuries. Stiegler (1998) described this widespread sense of disorientation:

[W]e are experiencing the deep opacity of contemporary technics; we do not understand what is being played out in technics, nor what is being transformed therein, even though we unceasingly have to make decisions regarding technics. . [I]n day to day technical reality, we cannot spontaneously distinguish the long-term processes of transformation from spectacular but fleeting technical innovations. (p. 21)"

This is arguably even more dire with LLMs - their impact on our collective memory (touched on in a musing below) is inevitably going to be profound, and I think pernicious.

 

 
Why grammati[s]ation? 

"Focusing on grammatization can help digital rhetoricians “distinguish the long-term processes of transformation from spectacular but fleeting technical innovations” (Stiegler, 1998, p. 21), and, most importantly, help us to identify robust categories of production and analysis integral to a variety of contemporary rhetorical situations. Electracy and remediation, I will argue, have only circled around this latter task."

Goes on to show how remediation functions primarily as a genealogy of a given technology/medium, and therefore fail to account for what is actually new about new media.

 
Technology constitute our experience and therefore our means of human becoming.

"Stiegler postulated that to study emerging media and writing technologies was to attend to the constitutive forces that condition the possibilities of human becoming, which were always shifting from epoch to epoch, especially in permanent innovation societies. Accordingly, his realignment of techno-human relations put writing at the epicenter of contemporary and projected cultural and ontological transformations. Humans, as a species, were not born into the world already equipped with mature cognitive capacities; these capacities developed over time in a transductive relationship with Neolithic technics, and they are still developing today hand in glove through our collective play with contemporary technics. Informed by philosopher Gilbert Simondon, Stiegler routinely defined technics as organized inorganic matter.” The term refers both to the history of fabricated objects (e.g., flint, hammers, pencils, computers) and to the domain of techne: the techniques and practices involved in making (something with) technology. Technics are more than merely a part of the environment humans inhabit; technics constitute—not determine—our experience on every possible level, from retention to anticipation, and from cultural history to genetics."

The "organised inorganic matter" comes directly from Simondon - computers, and LLMs by extension - are the same as hammers in this sense.

Similar to postphenomenology of Ihde and Verbeek

 
Humans and tech co-evolve through grammatisation

"Stiegler (2010a) asserted that “the static oppositions of Western metaphysics must be replaced by dynamic compositions: one must think in terms, not of hierarchies or totalizing systems, but of processes.” (p. 69). Beyond the dialogic sense of co-evolution, Stiegler circumvented the persistent opposition between humanity and technology that proponents of technogenesis still employ.3 Instead, critical attention starts by studying the constitutive processes that underwrite so-called humans and technologies—before considering them as separate, already-constituted entities. These constitutive processes, in Stiegler’s lexicon, are called processes of grammatization."

Again very similar to postphenomenology, which states the exact same thing-tech form humans form tech. Seems also quite like Simondon's concept of individuation, but in slightly different terms. 

This is one issue I take with the extended mind thesis - Clark especially believes we are natural born cyborgs, but fails to account for what might be lost when we replace certain cognitive functions with technics - the technologies only appropriate, but if they assume the position of a cognitive function, then our cognitive function matches that of the technology regardless of whether it is the same or not.

...This I suppose is the essence of simulacrum?

 
Gramme are the fabric of human becoming, historical change, social organisation

"Stiegler, even more than Derrida, professed to see life in the world—human becoming, historical change, social organization—as the evolution and play of gramme (the Greek word for “written mark”). What atoms are to physicists, gramme are to Stiegler."

 

 
Flux -> discrete elements. These elements allows disruption, transformation, reconfiguring the flux

"[...] the shift from hand-tools to factory machines is a process of grammatization, and so is genetic engineering—cells and organs become replicated and revised like a kind of alphabet. In every case, a continuous flux (e.g., speech, the body, the genome) becomes broken down into a system of discrete elements (e.g., alphabetic characters, mechanical systems, recombinant DNA sequences). And, in every case, the latter’s emergence always disrupts, transforms, and reconfigures the former"

 
Writing gave way to technical memory

"Gradually, the introduction of alphabetic writing furnished the Greeks with a new form of tertiary retention (or technical memory), and hence a new medium for educational practices. The students of early manuscript cultures (an elite group, to be sure) could inscribe the word into relative permanence, and do it without emotional identification, regular recitation, or a harmonious and mimetic style (the essential technics of oral poetry). Sharing the burden of memory with alphabetic writing materials, they were able to move from acts of recitation to exercises in abstraction (Havelock, 1963). More generally, grammatization “is the production and discretization of structures;” the formalization of a new gramme accrues through metonymic invention, whereby a part becomes detached from the whole of a continuous flux (Stiegler, 2011, p. 173)."

 
Grammatisation can be used for all tech. 

"Stiegler stretched grammatological theory even further, adapting it into a basis for understanding all manner of technical systems beyond those traditionally regarded as writing or communication technologies. In our age of ubicomp, this move is incredibly pertinent. Increasingly, more everyday objects are becoming smart objects, everyday practices are becoming digitally supplemented, and technics in every domain are becoming mnemotechnics (i.e., systems capable of capturing, storing, and sharing information). From an expanded notion of writing, Stiegler prompted us to recognize the expansive array of contemporary artif(acts) that now operate as gramme."

I think there's a case to be made that in many cases it doesn't just supplement, but supplant. Meta glasses being able to 'find' hidden keys means we don't even need to keep track of our keys (if anybody has keys nowadays).. What does that mean for instance for physical organisation? Who cares if our glasses are always there to be our eyes?

 
Grammes relate also to embodiment. Proletarianisation occurs through grammatising the labourer's gesture (action).

"This suggestive dimension of Stiegler’s (2012a) thought stems from his belief in a general interplay of gramme and gestures: “To separate the question of language, alphabet, photograph, cinematograph, audio recording, and so on from all the questions of gestures is a very big error.” Words, images, sounds: these are not the only gramme. According to Stiegler, some of the most important processes of grammatization—historically and especially today—involve the becoming-gramme of territories, bodies, and even cells. In addition to writing by virtue of bodily gestures, our seemingly non-discursive bodily gestures—by virtue of machines—can produce writing of sorts, to the extent that such gestures are been broken down from the flow of muscular continuity, detached from our bodies and iterable in their absence. For instance, the gesture or action of hammering a nail can be performed by a discreet and replicatable machinic configuration, just as the letters of the alphabet can be arranged to record a speaker’s every word. In grammatizing the laborer’s gesture, industrialization precipitates proletarianization, or “the loss of know-how” on the part of laborers (Stiegler, 2010a, p. 71). "

One important aspect here (ignoring the pride the workman takes in his physical labour, which is also important), is that assessing the quality of knowledge work (writing) is very difficult because it is inherently ambiguous. It's quality lies also in what was learned in the process (similar to the workman, but with differences). In this sense, the hammer goes in regardless of whether it is done by the workman or the machine, but with knowledge work, though the outcomes might functionally produce a similar bit of text (big if), then they are still not the same.

 

... continues

"For Stiegler, industrialization thus constitutes a pivotal stage of grammatization, which becomes intensified by digitization as industrial resources and investments center on the programming of behavioral models engendered through the production and commoditization of audiovisual media. Whereas prior grammatization processes dealt primarily in the “sphere of language, of logos” throughout much of writing’s history, industrialization “came to invest [in] the sphere of bodies,” and the age of mass media turned mechanization toward “apparatus-dependent reproducibilities of the visible and the audible” (Stiegler, 2010a, p. 70). "

RLHF workers for AI companies are literally filming everything to be able to automate every single human function (also the very point of meta glasses and the goal of that horrendous company). Ironically for text-training, some of these workers were fired for using AI to do their job - AI verifying AI leads to model collapse. There might also be another link here. Though prolitarianisation focuses on the labourer's know-how, Albert Borgmann's device paradigm says that something else is lost (for the consumer) when we let machines take over tasks.

The question is more so one of automation - what do we lose when we automate certain tasks? Not merely in the actual quality of the work, which in some cases would be actual gains, but in terms of things like skills, quality of life, expertise and deep knowledge of institutions and projects...

 

 

 
Link to Borgmann's Device. 

"Today, runners wearing a Nike+ sensor generate a digital data visualization as they run; each stride produces an indexical trace recorded and stored on an online database. They run, and their running generates computing, writing, or data in real-time. In addition to more traditional mnemotechnics, grammatization now engulfs all manner of machines, which variously enable and delimit a general writing of particular gestures and embodied activities. Defining all writing technologies as pharmakon, Stiegler (2011) warned that hyperindustrial investment in digital machines was contributing to a general proletarianization of the consumer’s existence to an even more pervasive extent than the industrial investment of factory machines effected a proletarianization of the worker’s labor."

Very much in line with Borgmann's device paradigm - something is lost in the consumer's existence.

 

 
Technics change our becoming human, even if they only offer an appropriation of what they supplement/supplant.

"Ultimately, Stiegler’s grammatological analysis of (hyper)industrial activities suggests an altogether different account of technical evolution and techno-human relations than the familiar notion of augmentation, which models all technologies as prosthetic extension of innate human capabilities. Conceived as processes of grammatization, the organization of inorganic matter that technologies are results not from “an extension of man” but an appropriation, a writing, defined by its disjunction from the continuity of a flux or movement, human or otherwise. Once disjointed and inscribed autonomously as inorganic matter, the movement becomes a gramme and, therefore, unfolds by the logic of the supplement and the nuclear traits of (arche-)writing. Theories rooted in augmentation cannot account for the autonomous, iterability of technics and their originary, constitutive force within the development of cultural practices, social organization, and even the human body itself."

This to me is a core issue of LLMs. They essentially outsource (downright supplant) thinking, but they're not thinking, so a person heavily reliant on LLMs do their thinking in the exact same manner as an LLM. For instance, in the original extended mind thesis paper by Chalmers and Clark, they show that keeping a notebook works directly as supplanting memory for a patient who can't remember. But the function of this person's memory is then also 'reduced' (arguably - some would argue augmented in some instances) to whatever the technology offers.

Typing speeds up recording of thoughts, but by doing so limit the time for thinking, making it suitable for recording ideas in a flow to later be organised and reflected upon, but offers no advantages, and definitely some disadvantages, for doing work that requires a deep, slow understanding - for instance note taking, writing a paper... (digital storage, collaboration practices, etc. in this case are different from the writing practice itself)...

Above - "a writing" refers then to the reduction of the physical world to symbols? It changes the very fabric of society and humanity and therefore, as stated, cultural practice, social organisation, even the human body.

 
Supplements are originary to human becoming

"Supplements, such as writing technologies, are originary to human becoming; the exteriority of technics exceeds and conditions the interior life of the mind, “the already-there inhabits invention itself” (Stiegler, 2009, p. 42). "

 
Grammatisation allows the analysis of techne to see what actually disrupts established gramme.

"Amid permanent innovation, one can approach changes in techne from the standpoint of Stiegler’s episteme (i.e., grammatization), in order to identify which processes of change actually disrupt established gramme and, in so doing, contribute the emergence of new gramme. Such becomes the criteria by which to evaluate and describe the (lack of) significance that any given permutation bears for the history and future of writing and rhetoric. If an apparent technological innovation does not markedly disrupt the history of supplementarity, or extend its logic to new domains, then it will not likely hold significance for digital rhetoric moving forward"

 
Grammatisation uses historical view (genealogy) like remediation, but also looks ahead.

"Grammatization, however, works rigorously on both sides of this dichotomy, oscillating between precedent and novelty. Media evolution is conceived as a matter of metonymic invention, whereby some part becomes detached from a continuous whole. This part, now discrete and iterable apart from the whole, acts as a gramme, which is to say it embodies the technics of writing, manifesting the logic of supplementarity within new spheres of practice. "

Another description of grammatisation as media evolution. 

 
How grammatisation uses history

"By contrast, grammatological analogies, which juxtapose the history and technics of writing with the present state of digital media, refer to older media with the aim of pinpointing:

1) disruptive or unprecedented aspects of emerging technologies, and

2) urgent tasks for theorists and practitioners concerned withthe cultural development of such technologies.

Comparing different processes of grammatization becomes a generative ground for conceptual invention, not a means of legitimating a myth of origin (like with remediation)

 

 
Blame not the medium

"YouTube—or, more accurately, the process of grammatization we can ascertain from its emergence—shows that electronic and digital media have not hopelessly handed over culture to the culture industry. In short-circuiting processes of collective individuation, the consumerist model of the cultural industry is the threat to democracy—not audiovisual production in and of itself, which is ultimately a pharmakon (Stiegler, 2010b)"

As I understand this - - - blame not the actual medium, but the conditions around it, because the medium is a pharmakon, meaning it can be both remedy and poison. This seems more true than ever - stealth adds through AI influencers, and earlier regular influencers, would have little incentive (beyond trolling, I suppose) unless it could generate income for the person doing it.

 
The tech itself doesn't reveal it's full capabilities (good or bad).

"Stiegler (2010b) claimed that “in its first stages of development, writing doesn’t produce any reflexivity” (p. 44), as he pointed out that cuneiform was performed exclusively by an elite class of scribes whose primary tasks focused on accounting and administrative recordkeeping."

This is also what postpheonmenology posits, namely that tech cannot be seen outside of how it is actually used. It's capabilities reveal themselves over time to reflect the needs and values of those who use them, and that would include the conditions surrounding it - as such, no tech is inherently evil.This is a sort of psychic and collective individuation.

...but perhaps a tech (like LLMs) have no actual use-case in which they are good? 

WIKINDX 6.18.1 | Total resources: 1595 | Username: -- | Bibliography: WIKINDX Master Bibliography | Style: American Psychological Association (APA) | Time Zone: Europe/Copenhagen (+01:00)