Sound Research WIKINDX |
![]() |
| Resource type: Journal Article Peer reviewed Published BibTeX citation key: Nony2024 Email resource to friend View all bibliographic details |
Language: en: English Categories: AI/Machine Learning Keywords: Artificial Intelligence, Philosophy, Philosophy of technology Creators: Nony Collection: Tropos. Rivista di Ermeneutica e Critica Filosofica |
Views: 20/43
|
| Abstract |
|
This article draws on Bernard Stiegler and Gilbert Simondon’s work to further interrogate the psychic, social, and political problems raised by the development of Artificial Intelligence. Stiegler’s political philosophy of time-consciousness reveals three concomitants urgencies: human memory is conditioned by industrial supplements that are increasingly disruptive, capitalism has produced an entropic condition where life on earth is threaten by toxic systems, the deployment of technologies of spirits has striped individuals of their psychic and collective individuation. I read media theory along with Simondon’s philosophy to elucidate the question of mediation in today’s reticulated AI-driven society.
Added by: alexb44 Last edited by: Mark Grimshaw-Aagaard |
| Notes |
|
Nony argues that the black box nature of AI transforms how we produce memory: "the operation of digital technologies outside human sensory-perception, and the extraction of data by machines for machines—force us to face a massive transformation in the production of memory. It is in this context that I situate my intervention. AI-powered media technology imposes a relation to information, which I name preemption" (p. 119-120).
Added by: alexb44 Last edited by: alexb44 |
| Quotes |
|
Proletarianisation - AI hides the how
"The automatized entropy of knowledge and thought occurs at two different scales of operation. First at an algorithmic level, industrial automata runs beyond and below human perception. According to Mark B. N. Hansen, the impact of media technology in the twenty-first century “affects the materiality of experience at a level more elemental than perception”. [...] these technologies now perform tasks at an algorithmic level, below the perceptive domain of human perception. The algorithmic scale of AI operations transforms the traditional mode of representation, the craft and know-how, into what Parisi calls a computational architecture of thought. Algorithm’s step-by-step procedure for calculation leads the programmable orientation of knowledge that Vilèm Flusser defines as modelling relations to the real. As such, AI-driven technologies are instructional programs designed to produce meaning through “a-significative units”, as Antoinette Rouvroy neatly calls them."
Added by: alexb44
04/11/2026, 09:57
Comments:
As shown also by the math problems 'solved' by AI. We get the result, but there is little actual knowledge in them, because nobody reached the conclusion.
Terrence Tao claims that it is often "along the way" that the significance of the solutions themselves become clear. Not to mention the sheer costs of these 'solutions'... Added by: alexb44 04/11/2026, 11:16 |
|
Sedimentation of knowledge destroyed - machine to machine instead (My emphasis)
"More importantly, and while the notion of tertiary retention—which defines the retention of memory into an artificial device such as a notepad or a camera—was mainly understood from the point of view of the human deliberately exteriorizing data via a technical supplement for the purpose of recollection, the digital has produced a new form of tertiary retention where machines exteriorized data for other machines to use. Such a shift forces us to acknowledge that there are at least two types of hypomnematon. One type that is human-generated, as when we write down a note in the form of orthographic writing where both writer and reader are “the bearers of knowledge that they necessarily embody.” This type of hypomnematon is the condition of possibility of knowing understood as a process of sedimentation. The other is generated by machines, as when applications collect data that are being analyzed by computers. By recognizing the different functions of these two types of tertiary memory, one can comprehend algorithmic procedures of extraction that strip subjects of their agency. The question of the proletarianization of the mind thus becomes the question of the future of knowledge formation as it depends on the memory that is now being automatically obtained from individuals whose data are being collected before they are recognized as information by individuals."
Added by: alexb44
04/11/2026, 09:50
Comments:
Pretty much how I see the issue of epistemology in LLM times... Typing in its own right doesn't affect this sedimentation, but LLMs alter what it means to write in academic circles. With this proletarianisation, agency moves to the machine, and so does intelligence. Users of LLMs are not reasons-responsive, and what becomes salient is not what is required for good writing. The benefits of writing, whether by pen or by keyboard, is partially the friction. LLMs supplant this process, so we need to think about exactly what the process of using LLMs brings with it in terms of writing/thinking...
Added by: alexb44
04/11/2026, 09:52
|